Corn’s clean-energy promise is clashing with its climate footprint

kAmu@C 564256D[ 4@C? 92D C6:8?65 @G6C p>6C:42? 28C:4F=EFC6] xE DAC2H=D 24C@DD h_ >:==:@? 24C6D — 23@FE E96 D:K6 @7 |@?E2?2 — 2?5 8@6D :?E@ 6G6CJE9:?8 7C@> =:G6DE@4< 7665 2?5 AC@46DD65 7@@5D E@ E96 6E92?@= 3=6?565 :?E@ >@DE @7 E96 ?2E:@?’D 82D@=:?6]k^Am

kAmqFE 2 8C@H:?8 3@5J @7 C6D62C49 C6G62=D E92E p>6C:42’D @3D6DD:@? H:E9 4@C? 92D 2 DE66A AC:46i %96 76CE:=:K6C FD65 E@ 8C@H :E :D H2C>:?8 E96 A=2?6E 2?5 4@?E2>:?2E:?8 H2E6C]k^Am

kAmr@C? :D 6DD6?E:2= E@ E96 CFC2= 64@?@>J 2?5 E@ E96 H@C=5’D 7@@5 DFAA=J[ 2?5 C6D62C496CD D2J E96 AC@3=6> :D?’E E96 4@C? :ED6=7] xE’D 9@H H6 8C@H :E]k^Am

kAmr@C? 72C>6CD C6=J @? 962GJ 76CE:=:K6C FD6 E@ DFDE2:? E@52J’D 9:89 J:6=5D] p?5 H96? E92E ?:EC@86? 3C62<D 5@H? :? E96 D@:=[ :E C6=62D6D ?:EC@FD @I:56[ 2 8C66?9@FD6 82D ?62C=J b__ E:>6D >@C6 A@E6?E E92? 42C3@? 5:@I:56] !C@5F4:?8 ?:EC@86? 76CE:=:K6C 2=D@ 6>:ED =2C86 2>@F?ED @7 42C3@? 5:@I:56[ 255:?8 E@ :ED 4=:>2E6 7@@EAC:?E]k^Am

kAmp8C:4F=EFC6 244@F?ED 7@C >@C6 E92? `_T @7 &]$] 8C66?9@FD6 82D 6>:DD:@?D[ 2?5 4@C? FD6D >@C6 E92? EH@\E9:C5D @7 2== ?:EC@86? 76CE:=:K6C ?2E:@?H:56 — >2<:?8 :E E96 =625:?8 5C:G6C @7 28C:4F=EFC2= ?:EC@FD @I:56 6>:DD:@?D[ DEF5:6D D9@H]k^Am

kAm%96 4@C? 2?5 6E92?@= :?5FDEC:6D :?D:DE E92E C2A:5 8C@HE9 :? 6E92?@= — H9:49 ?@H 4@?DF>6D >@C6 E92? c_T @7 E96 &]$] 4@C? 4C@A — :D 2 ?6E 6?G:C@?>6?E2= 36?67:E[ 2?5 E96J DEC@?8=J 5:DAFE6 C6D62C49 DF886DE:?8 @E96CH:D6]k^Am

kAm$:?46 a___[ &]$] 4@C? AC@5F4E:@? 92D DFC865 2=>@DE d_T[ 7FCE96C 255:?8 E@ E96 4C@A’D 4=:>2E6 :>A24E]k^Am

kAm*6E E96 6?G:C@?>6?E2= 4@DED @7 4@C? C2C6=J >2<6 9625=:?6D @C 724E@C :?E@ A@=:E:42= 5632E6D] |F49 @7 E96 5J?2>:4 EC246D 324< E@ 7656C2= A@=:4J — 2?5 E@ E96 A@H6C7F= 4@C? 2?5 6E92?@= =@33J E92E 96=A65 D92A6 :E]k^Am

kAm%96 #6?6H23=6 uF6= $E2?52C5[ A2DD65 :? E96 >:5\a___D[ C6BF:C65 E92E 82D@=:?6 36 3=6?565 H:E9 6E92?@=[ 2 3:@7F6= E92E :? E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D 4@>6D 2=>@DE 6?E:C6=J 7C@> 4@C?] %92E >2?52E6 5C@G6 FA 56>2?5 2?5 AC:46D 7@C 4@C?[ DAFCC:?8 72C>6CD E@ A=2?E >@C6 @7 :E]k^Am

kAm|2?J A=2?E 4@C? J62C 27E6C J62C @? E96 D2>6 =2?5] %96 AC24E:46[ 42==65 “4@?E:?F@FD 4@C?[” 56>2?5D >2DD:G6 2>@F?ED @7 ?:EC@86? 76CE:=:K6C 2?5 5C:G6D 6DA64:2==J 9:89 ?:EC@FD @I:56 6>:DD:@?D]k^Am

kAmpE E96 D2>6 E:>6[ 7656C2= DF3D:5:6D >2<6 :E >@C6 =F4C2E:G6 E@ 8C@H 4@C? E92? E@ 5:G6CD:7J] %2IA2J6CD 92G6 4@G6C65 >@C6 E92? Sd_ 3:==:@? :? 4@C? :?DFC2?46 AC6>:F>D @G6C E96 A2DE b_ J62CD[ 244@C5:?8 E@ 7656C2= 52E2 4@>A:=65 3J E96 t?G:C@?>6?E2= (@C<:?8 vC@FA]k^Am

kAm#6D62C496CD D2J AC@G6? 4@?D6CG2E:@? DE6AD — DF49 2D A=2?E:?8 C@HD @7 EC66D[ D9CF3D 2?5 8C2DD6D :? 4@C? 7:6=5D — 4@F=5 D92CA=J C65F46 E96D6 6>:DD:@?D] qFE E96 %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@? 92D 6=:>:?2E65 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8^ECF>AD\FD52\C6DFCC64ED\@?6\4=:>2E6\8C2?E\AC@8C2>\<:==D\2?@E96C^Qm>2?J @7 E96 :?46?E:G6D E92E 96=A65 72C>6CD ECJ DF49 AC24E:46Dk^2m]k^Am

kAmtIA6CED D2J :E 2== C2:D6D 2 =2C86C BF6DE:@?i x7 p>6C:42’D >@DE H:56=J A=2?E65 4C@A :D H@CD6?:?8 4=:>2E6 492?86[ D9@F=5?’E H6 368:? 8C@H:?8 :E 2 5:776C6?E H2Jn k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8Qmu=@@5=:89Ek^2m =@@<D :?E@ E96 :DDF6 96C6]k^Am

k9bmw@H 4@C? E@@< @G6C p>6C:42k^9bm

kAmr@C? 92D 366? 2 DE2A=6 @7 &]$] 28C:4F=EFC6 7@C 46?EFC:6D[ 7:CDE 5@>6DE:42E65 3J }2E:G6 p>6C:42?D 2?5 =2E6C FD65 3J tFC@A62? :>>:8C2?ED 2D 2 G6CD2E:=6 4C@A 7@C 7@@5 2?5 2?:>2= 7665] xED AC@5F4E:@? C62==J E@@< @77 :? E96 a___D 27E6C 7656C2= >2?52E6D 2?5 :?46?E:G6D 96=A65 EFC? >F49 @7 p>6C:42’D 4@C? 4C@A :?E@ 6E92?@=]k^Am

kAmr@C?’D 5@>:?2?46 — 2?5 E96 6>:DD:@?D E92E 4@>6 H:E9 :E — 5:5?’E 92AA6? 3J 244:56?E] xE H2D 3F:=E E9C@F89 2 9:89\5@==2C =@33J:?8 42>A2:8? E92E 4@?E:?F6D E@52J]k^Am

kAmx? E96 =2E6 `hh_D[ p>6C:42’D 4@C? 72C>6CD H6C6 :? EC@F3=6] !C:46D 925 4C2E6C65 2>:5 2 8=@32= 8C2:? 8=FE 2?5 E96 pD:2? 7:?2?4:2= 4C:D:D] p `hhh C6A@CE 3J E96 u656C2= #6D6CG6 q2?< @7 |:??62A@=:D D2:5 4C@A AC:46D 925 9:E “C@4< 3@EE@>]”k^Am

kAmx? a__` 2?5 a__a[ E96 7656C2= 8@G6C?>6?E 82G6 4@C? 72C>6CD 2?5 6E92?@= AC@5F46CD 2 3@@DE — 7:CDE E9C@F89 E96 &]$] s6A2CE>6?E @7 p8C:4F=EFC6’D q:@6?6C8J !C@8C2>[ H9:49 A2:5 6E92?@= AC@5F46CD E@ :?4C62D6 E96:C FD6 @7 72C> 4@>>@5:E:6D 7@C 7F6=] %96? E96 a__a u2C> q:== 4C62E65 AC@8C2>D E92E 4@?E:?F6 E@ DFAA@CE 6E92?@= 2?5 @E96C C6?6H23=6 6?6C8J]k^Am

kAmr@C? 8C@H6CD D@@? 27E6C >@F?E65 2? 2==\@FE 42>A2:8? :? (2D9:?8E@?] %96:C 8@2=i A6CDF256 r@?8C6DD E@ C6BF:C6 82D@=:?6 E@ 36 3=6?565 H:E9 6E92?@=] $E2E6 2?5 ?2E:@?2= 8C@H6C 8C@FAD =@33:65 C6=6?E=6DD=J[ A:E49:?8 6E92?@= 2D 2 H2J E@ 4FE 8C66?9@FD6 82DD6D[ C65F46 @:= 56A6?56?46 2?5 C6G:G6 CFC2= 64@?@>:6D]k^Am

kAm“(6 8@E 5@H? E@ 2 4@FA=6 @7 G@E6D :? r@?8C6DD[ 2?5 E96 4@C? 8C@H6CD H6C6 F?:E65 =:<6 ?6G6C 367@C6[” C642==65 y@? s@886EE[ E96? E96 :?5FDECJ’D 49:67 =@33J:DE[ :? 2? 2CE:4=6 AF3=:D965 3J E96 }2E:@?2= r@C? vC@H6CD pDD@4:2E:@?] “x DE2CE65 C646:G:?8 42==D 7C@> r2A:E@= w:== D2J:?8[ ‘(@F=5 J@F 92G6 J@FC 8C@H6CD DE@A 42==:?8 FDn (6 2C6 H:E9 J@F]’ x 925 ?@E D66? 2?JE9:?8 =:<6 :E 367@C6 2?5 92G6?’E D66? 2?JE9:?8 =:<6 :E D:?46]”k^Am

kAm%96:C A6CD:DE6?46 A2:5 @77] x? a__d[ r@?8C6DD 4C62E65 E96 #6?6H23=6 uF6= $E2?52C5 W#u$X[ H9:49 C6BF:C6D E92E 2 46CE2:? 2>@F?E @7 6E92?@= 36 3=6?565 :?E@ &]$] 82D@=:?6 6249 J62C] %H@ J62CD =2E6C[ =2H>2<6CD 6IA2?565 :E 7FCE96C] %96 A@=:4J EC2?D7@C>65 E96 >2C<6Ei %96 2>@F?E @7 4@C? FD65 7@C 6E92?@= 5@>6DE:42==J 92D >@C6 E92? EC:A=65 :? E96 A2DE a_ J62CD]k^Am

k7:8FC6mk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]DE24<6C]4@>^H^`ag_^:>286D^DE@C:6D^a_ad^`a^`_^7=@@5=:89E\4@C?D\4=62?\6?6C8J\a]A?8Q 2=ElQr92CE D9@H:?8 C2E6 @7 &]$] 4@C? AC@5F4E:@? 92D DFC865 36EH66? `ha_ 2?5 a_acj uC@> a___ E@ a_ac[ &]$] AC@5F4E:@? ;F>A65 d_T 27E6C E96 #6?6H23=6 uF6= $E2?52C5 H2D 4C62E65]Q DEJ=6lQH:5E9i `__TQ ^mk7:842AE:@?m#@D:6 v:==:6D ^^ u=@@5=:89Ek^7:842AE:@?mk^7:8FC6m

kAm(96? 56>2?5 7@C 4@C? DA:<65 2D 2 C6DF=E @7 E96 #u$[ :E AFD965 FA AC:46D H@C=5H:56[ D2:5 %:> $62C49:?86C[ 2 C6D62C496C 2E !C:?46E@? &?:G6CD:EJ’D $49@@= @7 !F3=:4 2?5 x?E6C?2E:@?2= p772:CD] %96 C6DF=E[ $62C49:?86C D2:5[ :D E92E >@C6 =2?5 2C@F?5 E96 H@C=5 8@E 4=62C65 E@ 8C@H 4@C?] %92E[ :? EFC?[ C6DF=E65 :? >@C6 6>:DD:@?D]k^Am

kAm%92E =@33J:?8 3C@F89E 4=@FE] “z:?8 r@C?” 3642>6 2 A@=:E:42= 7@C46[ 4@FCE65 3J AC6D:56?E:2= 9@A67F=D 2?5 AC@E64E65 3J 3@E9 A2CE:6D] $:?46 a_`_[ ?2E:@?2= 4@C? 2?5 6E92?@= EC256 8C@FAD 92G6 DA6?E >@C6 E92? Sdd >:==:@? @? =@33J:?8 2?5 >:==:@?D >@C6 @? A@=:E:42= 5@?2E:@?D[ 244@C5:?8 E@ 42>A2:8? 7:?2?46 C64@C5D 2?2=JK65 3J u=@@5=:89E]k^Am

kAmx? a_ac 2=@?6[ E9@D6 EC256 8C@FAD DA6?E EH:46 2D >F49 @? =@33J:?8 2D E96 }2E:@?2= #:7=6 pDD@4:2E:@?] |2;@C :?5FDECJ A=2J6CD — pC496C s2?:6=D |:5=2?5[ r2C8:== 2?5 6E92?@= 8:2?E !~t% 2>@?8 E96> — 92G6 A@FC65 6G6? >@C6 :?E@ (2D9:?8E@?[ 6?DFC:?8 E96 D64E@C’D G@:46 C6>2:?D @?6 @7 E96 =@F56DE :? &]$] 28C:4F=EFC6]k^Am

kAm}@H E9@D6 D2>6 8C@FAD 2C6 AFD9:?8 7@C E96 ?6IE 3:8 AC:K6i 6IA2?5:?8 9:896C\6E92?@= 82D@=:?6 3=6?5D 2?5 A@D:E:@?:?8 6E92?@=\32D65 ;6E 7F6= 2D 2G:2E:@?’D “=@H\42C3@?” 7FEFC6]k^Am

k9bm#6D62C49 F?56C4FED 6E92?@=’D 4=62?\7F6= 4=2:>Dk^9bm

kAmr@C? 2?5 6E92?@= EC256 8C@FAD 5:5?’E >2<6 E96:C @77:4:2=D 2G2:=23=6 7@C :?E6CG:6HD]k^Am

kAmqFE @? E96:C H63D:E6D 2?5 :? E96:C =:E6C2EFC6[ E96J 92G6 AC@>@E65 4@C? 6E92?@= 2D 2 4=:>2E6\7C:6?5=J 7F6=]k^Am

kAm%96 #6?6H23=6 uF6=D pDD@4:2E:@? 4:E6D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^7:=6D]4E4EFD6C4@?E6?E]4@>^2gg__5`be_`^6a7cd`7b\_ab`\chce\2g54\bbddeahf52eb]A57nC67l7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8Qm8@G6C?>6?E 2?5 F?:G6CD:EJ C6D62C49k^2m E92E 7:?5D 3FC?:?8 6E92?@= C65F46D 8C66?9@FD6 82D 6>:DD:@?D 3J C@F89=J c_T\d_T 4@>A2C65 H:E9 82D@=:?6] %96 6E92?@= :?5FDECJ D2JD E96 4=:>2E6 4C:E:4D 92G6 :E HC@?8 — 2?5 E92E >@DE @7 E96 4@C? FD65 7@C 7F6= 4@>6D 7C@> 36EE6C J:6=5D 2?5 D>2CE6C 72C>:?8[ ?@E 7C@> A=@H:?8 FA ?6H =2?5] %96 2>@F?E @7 76CE:=:K6C C6BF:C65 E@ AC@5F46 2 3FD96= @7 4@C? 92D 5C@AA65 D92CA=J :? C646?E 564256D[ E96J D2J]k^Am

kAm“tE92?@= C65F46D 42C3@? 6>:DD:@?D[ C6>@G:?8 E96 42C3@? 6BF:G2=6?E @7 `a >:==:@? 42CD 7C@> E96 C@25 6249 J62C[” 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 #6?6H23=6 uF6=D pDD@4:2E:@?]k^Am

kAmvC@HE9 t?6C8J[ 2 >2;@C 6E92?@= EC256 8C@FA[ D2:5 :? 2 HC:EE6? DE2E6>6?E E@ u=@@5=:89E E92E &]$] 72C>6CD 2?5 3:@7F6= AC@5F46CD 2C6 “4@?DE2?E=J 7:?5:?8 ?6H H2JD E@ >2<6 E96:C @A6C2E:@?D >@C6 677:4:6?E 2?5 >@C6 6?G:C@?>6?E2==J 36?67:4:2=[” FD:?8 E9:?8D =:<6 4@G6C 4C@AD E@ C65F46 E96:C 42C3@? 7@@EAC:?E]k^Am

kAmQq:@7F6= AC@5F46CD 2C6 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^67:7@F?52E:@?]@C8^7@F?52E:@?\C6A@CED^2\DEC2E68:4\C@25>2A\7@C\5642C3@?:K:?8\6E92?@=\:?\E96\F?:E65\DE2E6D^nC67l7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8Qm>2<:?8 :?G6DE>6?ED E@52Jk^2m E92E H:== >2<6 E96:C AC@5F4ED ?6E\K6C@ @C 6G6? ?6E ?682E:G6 :? E96 ?6IE EH@ 564256D[Q E96 DE2E6>6?E D2:5]k^Am

kAmqFE D@>6 C6D62C49 E6==D 2 5:776C6?E DE@CJ]k^Am

kAmp C646?E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]6H8]@C8^C6D62C49^76CE:=:K:?8\4@?E:?F@FD\4@C?\5C:G6D\>2;@C\D@FC46\72C>\8C66?9@FD6\82D6D\4@?D6CG2E:@?\42?nC67l7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8Qmt?G:C@?>6?E2= (@C<:?8 vC@FA C6A@CEk^2m 7:?5D E92E E96 H2J 4@C? :D 8C@H? :? >F49 @7 E96 |:5H6DE — H:E9 E96 D2>6 7:6=5D A=2?E65 :? 4@C? J62C 27E6C J62C — 42CC:6D 2 962GJ 4=:>2E6 4@DE]k^Am

kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]A?2D]@C8^5@:^`_]`_fb^A?2D]a`_`_gc``hnC67l7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8Qm#6D62C49k^2m :? a_aa 3J 28C:4F=EFC2= =2?5 FD6 6IA6CE %J=6C {2C< 2?5 4@==628F6D =:?<D E96 #6?6H23=6 uF6= $E2?52C5 E@ 6IA2?565 4@C? 4F=E:G2E:@?[ 962G:6C 76CE:=:K6C FD6[ H@CD6?:?8 H2E6C A@==FE:@? 2?5 :?4C62D65 6>:DD:@?D] $4:6?E:DED EJA:42==J 4@?G6CE 8C66?9@FD6 82DD6D =:<6 ?:EC@FD @I:56 2?5 >6E92?6 :?E@ E96:C 42C3@?\5:@I:56 6BF:G2=6?ED — @C 42C3@? :?E6?D:EJ — D@ E96:C H2C>:?8 :>A24ED 42? 36 4@>A2C65 @? E96 D2>6 D42=6]k^Am

kAm“%96 42C3@? :?E6?D:EJ @7 4@C? 6E92?@= AC@5F465 F?56C E96 #u$ :D ?@ =6DD E92? 82D@=:?6 2?5 =:<6=J 2E =62DE acT 9:896C[” E96 2FE9@CD 4@?4=F565]k^Am

k7:8FC6mk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]DE24<6C]4@>^H^`ag_^:>286D^DE@C:6D^a_ad^`a^`_^7=@@5=:89E\4@C?D\4=62?\6?6C8J\b];A8Q 2=ElQv2D AF>A A9@E@ 2E f\6=6G6? D9@H:?8 E9C66 8C256D @7 82D[ 2 AF>A[ H:E9 2 DE:4<6C E92E D2JD Q DEJ=6lQH:5E9i `__TQ ^mk7:842AE:@?mp>6D p=6I2?56C ^^ u=@@5=:89Ek^7:842AE:@?mk^7:8FC6m

kAm{2C<’D C6D62C49 92D 366? 5:DAFE65 3J D4:6?E:DED 2E pC8@??6 }2E:@?2= {23@C2E@CJ[ !FC5F6 &?:G6CD:EJ 2?5 E96 &?:G6CD:EJ @7 x==:?@:D[ H9@ AF3=:D965 2 7@C>2= C63FEE2= 2C8F:?8 E96 DEF5J C6=:65 @? “BF6DE:@?23=6 2DDF>AE:@?D” 2?5 72F=EJ >@56=:?8 — 2 492C86 {2C<’D E62> 92D C6;64E65]k^Am

kAmp k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]82@]8@G^2DD6ED^82@\`f\hc]A57nC67l7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8Qma_`f C6A@CEk^2m 3J E96 &]$] v@G6C?>6?E p44@F?E23:=:EJ ~77:46 7@F?5 E92E E96 #u$ H2D F?=:<6=J E@ >66E :ED 8C66?9@FD6 82D 8@2=D 3642FD6 E96 &]$] C6=:6D AC65@>:?2?E=J @? 4@C? 6E92?@= 2?5 AC@5F46D C6=2E:G6=J =:EE=6 @7 E96 4=62?6C[ 25G2?465 3:@7F6=D >256 7C@> H2DE6]k^Am

kAm%96 AC@3=6> :D?’E ;FDE 6>:DD:@?D[ C6D62C496CD D2J] r@C? 6E92?@= C6BF:C6D >:==:@?D @7 24C6D E92E 4@F=5 :?DE625 36 FD65 7@C 7@@5 4C@AD @C >@C6 677:4:6?E 6?6C8J D@FC46D] ~?6 C646?E DEF5J 7@F?5 E92E D@=2C A2?6=D 42? 86?6C2E6 2D >F49 6?6C8J 2D 4@C? 6E92?@= @? C@F89=J bT @7 E96 =2?5]k^Am

kAm“xE’D ;FDE 2 E6CC:3=6 FD6 @7 =2?5[” $62C49:?86C[ E96 !C:?46E@? C6D62C496C[ D2:5 @7 6E92?@=] “p?5 J@F 42?VE D@=G6 4=:>2E6 492?86 :7 J@F’C6 8@:?8 E@ >2<6 DF49 E6CC:3=6 FD6 @7 =2?5]”k^Am

kAm|@DE @7 E96 4@F?ECJ’D E@A 4C@A :D?’E 7665:?8 A6@A=6] |@C6 E92? c_T @7 &]$] 4@C? 8@6D E@ 6E92?@=] p D:>:=2C 2>@F?E :D FD65 E@ 7665 =:G6DE@4<[ 2?5 ;FDE `aT 6?5D FA 2D 7@@5 @C :? @E96C FD6D]k^Am

k7:8FC6mk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]DE24<6C]4@>^H^`ag_^:>286D^DE@C:6D^a_ad^`a^`_^7=@@5=:89E\4@C?D\4=62?\6?6C8J\d];A8Q 2=ElQ!9@E@ @7 3=24< 2?5 H9:E6 4@HD @? 72C> =2?5 ?62C 2 82E6 2?5 76?46 C6AC6D6?E:?8 9@H 42EE=6 2?5 @E96C =:G6DE@4< 62E >@C6 E92? c_T @7 E96 4@C? 8C@H? :? E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D 2?5 @?=J `aT @7 4@C? 6?5D FA 2D 7@@5 7@C A6@A=6 @C :? @E96C FD6D]Q DEJ=6lQH:5E9i `__TQ ^mk7:842AE:@?ms66 y] w2== ^^ u=@@5=:89Ek^7:842AE:@?mk^7:8FC6m

k9bmk3C ^mpD 4@C? AC@5F4E:@? C:D6D[ D@ 92G6 6>:DD:@?Dk^9bm

kAmv=@32==J[ 4@C? AC@5F4E:@? 5@F3=65 7C@> a___ E@ a_a`]k^Am

kAm%92E 8C@HE9 92D 366? 7F6=65 3J 76CE:=:K6C[ H9:49 6>:ED ?:EC@FD @I:56 E92E 42? =:?86C :? E96 2E>@DA96C6 7@C >@C6 E92? 2 46?EFCJ] %92E 62ED 2H2J 2E E96 @K@?6 =2J6C[ H9:49 3=@4<D >@DE @7 E96 DF?’D 92C>7F= F=EC2G:@=6E C25:2E:@?]k^Am

kAmv=@32= 6>:DD:@?D 92G6 D@2C65 2=@?8D:56 4@C? AC@5F4E:@?] q6EH66? `hg_ 2?5 a_a_[ ?:EC@FD @I:56 6>:DD:@?D 7C@> 9F>2? 24E:G:EJ 4=:>365 c_T[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^6DD5]4@A6C?:4FD]@C8^2CE:4=6D^`e^adcb^a_ac^nC67l7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8QmE96 v=@32= r2C3@? !C@;64Ek^2m 7@F?5]k^Am

kAmx? E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D[ ?:EC@FD @I:56 6>:DD:@?D 7C@> 28C:4F=EFC6 :? a_aa H6C6 6BF2= E@ C@F89=J aea >:==:@? >6EC:4 E@?D @7 42C3@? 5:@I:56[ 244@C5:?8 E@ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]6A2]8@G^DJDE6>^7:=6D^5@4F>6?ED^a_ac\_c^FD\898\:?G6?E@CJ\a_ac\492AE6C\d\28C:4F=EFC6]A57nC67l7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8QmE96 t!p’D :?G6?E@CJ @7 8C66?9@FD6 82D 6>:DD:@?D]k^2m %92E’D 6BF:G2=6?E E@ AFEE:?8 2=>@DE de >:==:@? A2DD6?86C 42CD @? E96 C@25]k^Am

kAm%96 3:886DE :?4C62D6D 2C6 4@>:?8 DEC2:89E 7C@> E96 r@C? q6=E]k^Am

k7:8FC6mk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]DE24<6C]4@>^H^`ag_^:>286D^DE@C:6D^a_ad^`a^`_^7=@@5=:89E\4@C?D\4=62?\6?6C8J\c];A8Q 2=ElQvC2A9:4 @7 7@FC >2AD D9@H:?8 E92E 6>:DD:@?D @7 8C66?9@FD6 82D ?:EC@FD @I:56 92G6 D@2C65 :? p>6C:42UCDBF@jD r@C? q6=E 36EH66? `h__ 2?5 a_`_]Q DEJ=6lQH:5E9i `__TQ ^mk7:842AE:@?mt?G:C@?>6?E2= (@C<:?8 vC@FA G:DF2=:K2E:@? @7 ?:EC@FD @I:56 52E2 7C@> x@H2 $E2E6 &?:G6CD:EJ C6D62C496C r92@BF? {F 2?5 4@==628F6D]k^7:842AE:@?mk^7:8FC6m

kAmtE92?@=’D 4=:>2E6 7@@EAC:?E :D?’E E96 @?=J 4@?46C?] %96 ?:EC@86? FD65 E@ 8C@H 4@C? 2?5 @E96C 4C@AD :D 2=D@ 2 <6J D@FC46 @7 5C:?<:?8 H2E6C A@==FE:@?]k^Am

kAmp44@C5:?8 E@ 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]4=62?H:D4@?D:?]@C8^HA\4@?E6?E^FA=@25D^a_ad^_h^pv{0}:EC2E6#6A@CE0$6AEa_ad0u:?2=]A57nC67l7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8Qm?6H C6A@CE 3J E96 p==:2?46 7@C E96 vC62E {2<6D 2?5 r=62? (:D4@?D:?k^2m[ >@C6 E92? h_T @7 ?:EC2E6 4@?E2>:?2E:@? :? (:D4@?D:?’D 8C@F?5H2E6C :D =:?<65 E@ 28C:4F=EFC2= D@FC46D — >@DE=J DJ?E96E:4 76CE:=:K6C 2?5 >2?FC6]k^Am

kAm%96 D2>6 2?2=JD:D 6DE:>2E6D E92E :? a_aa[ 72C>6CD 2AA=:65 >@C6 E92? `e >:==:@? A@F?5D @7 ?:EC@86? 36J@?5 H92E 4C@AD ?66565[ D6?5:?8 CF?@77 :?E@ H6==D[ DEC62>D 2?5 @E96C H2E6C DJDE6>D]k^Am

kAmu@C 72>:=:6D =:<6 %J=6C uCJ6’D[ E92E 9:ED 4=@D6 E@ 9@>6] x? a_aa[ uCJ6 2?5 9:D H:76 >@G65 :?E@ 2 ?6H 9@>6 :? E96 CFC2= G:==286 @7 r2D4@[ (:D4@?D:?[ 23@FE a_ >:=6D 62DE @7 vC66? q2J] p 7C66 E6DE D@@? 27E6CH2C5 7@F?5 E96:C H6== H2E6C 925 ?:EC2E6 =6G6=D >@C6 E92? EH:46 E96 t!p’D D276 =:>:E] “(6 H6C6 AC6EEJ D9@4<65[” 96 D2:5]k^Am

kAmuCJ6 :?DE2==65 2 C6G6CD6\@D>@D:D DJDE6> :? E96 32D6>6?E 2?5 DE:== 3FJD 3@EE=65 H2E6C 7@C 9:D H:76[ H9@ :D 3C62DE7665:?8 E96:C 52F89E6C[ 3@C? :? yF=J]k^Am

kAm~?6 =:<6=J 4F=AC:E[ 96 DFDA64ED[ 2C6 E96 4@C?7:6=5D =6DD E92? a__ J2C5D 7C@> 9:D 9@>6]k^Am

kAm“rC@AD =:<6 4@C? C6BF:C6 2 =@E @7 ?:EC@86?[” 96 D2:5] “p =@E @7 E92E DEF77[ x 2DDF>6[ :D 86EE:?8 :?E@ E96 H6== H2E6C 2?5 DFC7246 H2E6C]”k^Am

kAm(96? 96 H2E496D >2?FC6 @C 76CE:=:K6C 36:?8 DAC625 @? ?62C3J 7:6=5D[ 96 D2:5[ @?6 BF6DE:@? ?28D 9:>i “(96C6 5@6D E92E 8@n”k^Am

k9bm(92E 4=62?6C 4@C? 4@F=5 =@@< =:<6k^9bm

kAm#65F4:?8 4@C?’D 4=:>2E6 7@@EAC:?E :D A@DD:3=6 — 3FE E96 72C>6CD ECJ:?8 E@ 5@ :E 2C6 DH:>>:?8 282:?DE E96 A@=:4J E:56]k^Am

kAm%96 ~?6 q:8 q62FE:7F= q:== p4E[ 324<65 3J !C6D:56?E s@?2=5 %CF>A 2?5 4@?8C6DD:@?2= #6AF3=:42?D[ DEC:AD @FE E96 AC@G:D:@?D @7 !C6D:56?E y@6 q:56?’D x?7=2E:@? #65F4E:@? p4E E92E 925 C6H2C565 72C>6CD 7@C 4=:>2E6\7C:6?5=J AC24E:46D]k^Am

kAmp?5 :? pAC:=[ %CF>A’D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8^ECF>AD\FD52\C6DFCC64ED\@?6\4=:>2E6\8C2?E\AC@8C2>\<:==D\2?@E96C^Qm&$sp 42?46=65 E96 Sb 3:==:@? !2CE?6CD9:AD 7@C r=:>2E6\$>2CE r@>>@5:E:6D :?:E:2E:G6k^2m[ 2 8C2?E AC@8C2> 56D:8?65 E@ AC@>@E6 72C>:?8 2?5 7@C6DECJ AC24E:46D E@ :>AC@G6 D@:= 2?5 C65F46 8C66?9@FD6 82D 6>:DD:@?D] %96 286?4J D2:5 E92E E96 AC@8C2>’D 25>:?:DEC2E:G6 4@DED >62?E E@@ =:EE=6 >@?6J H2D C6249:?8 72C>6CD[ H9:=6 p8C:4F=EFC6 $64C6E2CJ qC@@<6 #@==:?D 5:D>:DD65 :E 2D A2CE @7 E96 “8C66? ?6H D42>]”k^Am

kAm&?:G6CD:EJ @7 x@H2 AC@76DD@C $:=G:2 $6449: D2:5 E96 C@==324< @7 E96 r=:>2E6\$>2CE AC@8C2> 92D 2=C625J 8:G6? 72C>6CD “4@=5 766E” 23@FE 25@AE:?8 4@?D6CG2E:@? AC24E:46D] “%96 :>A24E @7 E9:D 92D 366? 56G2DE2E:?8[” D2:5 $6449:[ 2 ?2EFC2= C6D@FC46D 64@?@>:DE H9@ E62496D 2E E96 F?:G6CD:EJ’D $49@@= @7 t2CE9[ t?G:C@?>6?E 2?5 $FDE2:?23:=:EJ]k^Am

kAm#6D62C49 D9@HD H92E’D A@DD:3=6 :7 72C>6CD 925 DFAA@CE] x? :ED C646?E C6A@CE[ E96 t?G:C@?>6?E2= (@C<:?8 vC@FA 7@F?5 E92E 7@FC AC@G6? 4@?D6CG2E:@? AC24E:46D — :?4=F5:?8 A=2?E:?8 EC66D[ D9CF3D 2?5 96586C@HD :? 4@C? 7:6=5D — 4@F=5 >2<6 2 >62DFC23=6 5:776C6?46]k^Am

kAmx>A=6>6?E:?8 E9@D6 AC24E:46D @? ;FDE cT @7 4@?E:?F@FD 4@C? 24C6D 24C@DD x==:?@:D[ x@H2[ |:??6D@E2 2?5 (:D4@?D:? H@F=5 4FE E@E2= 8C66?9@FD6 82D 6>:DD:@?D 3J E96 6BF:G2=6?E @7 E2<:?8 >@C6 E92? gd_[___ 82D@=:?6 42CD @77 E96 C@25[ t(v 7@F?5]k^Am

kAms6DA:E6 D6E324<D 2E E96 7656C2= =6G6=[ D@>6 72C>6CD 2C6 2=C625J D9@H:?8 H92E 2 >@C6 4=:>2E6\7C:6?5=J r@C? q6=E 4@F=5 =@@< =:<6]k^Am

kAmx? ?@CE96C? x@H2[ (6?5J y@9?D@? 72C>D `[a__ 24C6D @7 4@C? 2?5 D@J362?D H:E9 96C 72E96C] ~? `b_ @7 E9@D6 24C6D[ D96’D ECJ:?8 D@>6E9:?8 5:776C6?Ei $96’D A=2?E:?8 7CF:E 2?5 ?FE EC66D[ @C82?:4 8C2:?D[ D9CF3D 2?5 @E96C A=2?ED E92E ?665 =:EE=6 @C ?@ ?:EC@86? 76CE:=:K6C]k^Am

kAm“%96 >@C6 A6C6??:2=D H6 42? 92G6 @? E96 8C@F?5[ E96 36EE6C :E :D 7@C E96 4=:>2E6[” D96 D2:5]k^Am

kAmp4C@DD E96 C6DE @7 E96 72C>[ E96J 6?C:49 E96 D@:= 3J C@E2E:?8 4C@AD 2?5 A=2?E:?8 4@G6C 4C@AD] %96J’G6 2=D@ 4@?G6CE65 =6DD AC@5F4E:G6 A2CED @7 E96 7:6=5D :?E@ “AC2:C:6 DEC:AD” — 32?5D @7 AC2:C:6 8C2DD E92E DE@C6 42C3@? 2?5 C6BF:C6 ?@ 76CE:=:K6C]k^Am

kAm&?56C E96 ?@H\42?46=65 r=:>2E6\$>2CE 8C2?E AC@8C2>[ E96J H6C6 DFAA@D65 E@ C646:G6 E649?:42= 2DD:DE2?46 2?5 23@FE Sa_[___ 2 J62C E@ 6IA2?5 E9@D6 AC24E:46D] %96 8C2?E AC@8C2> H2D E6C>:?2E65 367@C6 E96J 8@E 2?J @7 E96 >@?6J]k^Am

kAm“xE’D 92C5 E@ E2<6 C:D<D @? J@FC @H?[” y@9?D@? D2:5] “%92E’D H96C6 7656C2= DFAA@CE C62==J 96=AD] q642FD6 28C:4F=EFC6 :D 2 9:89\C:D< @44FA2E:@?]”k^Am

kAm%96 64@?@>:4D DE:== 72G@C 3FD:?6DD 2D FDF2=] y@9?D@? <?@HD E92E >2?J |:5H6DE6C? 4@C? 8C@H6CD 766= AC6DDFC6 E@ >2I:>:K6 J:6=5D[ <66A:?8 E96> 9@@<65 @? 4@C? — 2?5 ?:EC@86? 76CE:=:K6C]k^Am

kAm“x E9:?< 2 =@E @7 72C>6CD 2C@F?5 96C6 2C6 G6CJ 2==6C8:4 E@ EC66D[” D96 ;@<65]k^Am

kAmx? D@FE962DE x@H2[ D:IE9\86?6C2E:@? 72C>6C {6G: {J=6[ H9@ >:I6D @C82?:4 2?5 4@?G6?E:@?2= >6E9@5D 24C@DD ah_ 24C6D[ FD6D 2 E9C66\J62C C@E2E:@?[ 6IE6?D:G6 4@G6C 4C@AD 2?5 2 E649?:BF6 42==65 C@==6C\4C:>A:?8 — 7=2EE6?:?8 CJ6 6249 DAC:?8 E@ 4C62E6 2 >F=49 E92E DFAAC6DD6D H665D[ 7665D E96 D@:= 2?5 C65F46D 76CE:=:K6C ?665D]k^Am

kAm“%96 C@==6C 4C:>A:?8 @7 4@G6C 4C@AD :D 2 9F86[ 9F86 @AA@CEF?:EJ E@ D6BF6DE6C >@C6 42C3@?[ :>AC@G6 D@:= 962=E9[ D2G6 >@?6J @? 496>:42=D 2?5 DE:== 86E 2 D:>:=2C J:6=5[” 96 D2:5]k^Am

kAmqFE 72C>6CD 86E 76H 8@G6C?>6?E :?46?E:G6D E@ E2<6 DF49 4=:>2E6\7C:6?5=J DE6AD[ {J=6 D2:5] “%96C6 :D 2 =24< @7 D6C:@FD?6DD 23@FE DFAA@CE:?8 72C>6CD E@ :>A=6>6?E E96D6 ?6H AC24E:46D[” 96 D2:5]k^Am

kAmp?5 H:E9@FE 7656C2= AC@8C2>D E@ @77D6E E96 C:D<[ E96 :??@G2E:@?D E92E {J=6 2?5 y@9?D@? 2C6 ECJ:?8 C6>2:? 6I46AE:@?D — ?@E E96 ?@C>]k^Am

kAm|2?J 72C>6CD DE:== D66 AC2:C:6 DEC:AD @C A2E496D @7 EC66D 2D 2 H2DE6[ D2:5 {F<6 vC2?[ H9@D6 4@>A2?J 96=AD x@H2 72C>6CD 6DE23=:D9 A6C6??:2=D]k^Am

kAm“|J 6J6D 5@ ?@E =:6[” vC2? D2:5] “x 92G6 ?@E D66? 6IE6?D:G6 492?86 E@ 4@G6C 4C@AA:?8 @C E:==286 24C@DD E96 3C@25 24C6286 @7 E9:D DE2E6 E92E x =@G6]”k^Am

k7:8FC6mk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]DE24<6C]4@>^H^`ag_^:>286D^DE@C:6D^a_ad^`a^`_^7=@@5=:89E\4@C?D\4=62?\6?6C8J\e];A8Q 2=ElQr@C? :D =@2565 :?E@ 2 D6>:\EC2:=6C 7@C EC2?DA@CE 2E 2 8C2:? E6C>:?2= :? u:E493FC8[ (:D4@?D:?]Q DEJ=6lQH:5E9i `__TQ ^mk7:842AE:@?ms66 y] w2== ^^ u=@@5=:89Ek^7:842AE:@?mk^7:8FC6m

k9bmk3C ^m%96 ?6IE 4@C? 3@@>nk^9bm

kAms6DA:E6 >@F?E:?8 C6D62C49 23@FE 4@C?’D 4=:>2E6 4@DED[ :?5FDECJ 8C@FAD 2C6 AFD9:?8 7@C A@=:4:6D E@ 3@@DE 6E92?@= 56>2?5]k^Am

kAm~?6 3:8 AC:@C:EJi !FD9:?8 2 3:== E@ C6BF:C6 E92E ?6H 42CD 2C6 23=6 E@ CF? @? 82D H:E9 >@C6 6E92?@= E92? H92E’D 4@>>@?=J D@=5 E@52J]k^Am

kAmr@C? 2?5 3:@7F6= EC256 8C@FAD 92G6 2=D@ 366? AC6DD:?8 s6>@4C2ED 2?5 #6AF3=:42?D :? r@?8C6DD 7@C =68:D=2E:@? E@ A2G6 E96 H2J 7@C 6E92?@=\32D65 ;6E 7F6=] (9:=6 FD6 @7 DF49 “DFDE2:?23=6” 2G:2E:@? 7F6= :D DE:== :? :ED 62C=J DE286D 5@>6DE:42==J[ 4@C? 2?5 3:@7F6= 2DD@4:2E:@?D 92G6 >256 56G6=@A:?8 2 >2C<6E 7@C :E 2 E@A A@=:4J AC:@C:EJ]k^Am

kAm$6449:[ E96 x@H2 AC@76DD@C[ D2JD :E’D 62DJ E@ D66 H9J 6E92?@= AC@5F46CD 2C6 ECJ:?8 E@ 6IA2?5 E96:C >2C<6Ei %96 8C@HE9 :? 6=64EC:4 G69:4=6D E9C62E6?D =@?8\E6C> 82D@=:?6 D2=6D]k^Am

kAm#6D62C496CD H2C? E92E AC@5F4:?8 6?@F89 6E92?@=\32D65 ;6E 7F6= 4@F=5 EC:886C >2;@C =2?5\FD6 D9:7ED] k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]HC:]@C8^:?D:89ED^FD\DFDE2:?23=6\2G:2E:@?\7F6=\6>:DD:@?D\:>A24EDnC67l7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8Qmp a_ac (@C=5 #6D@FC46D x?DE:EFE6 2?2=JD:Dk^2m 7@F?5 E92E >66E:?8 E96 7656C2= 8@2= @7 bd 3:==:@? 82==@?D @7 6E92?@= ;6E 7F6= H@F=5 C6BF:C6 23@FE ``c >:==:@? 24C6D @7 4@C? — C@F89=J a_T >@C6 4@C? 24C6286 E92? E96 &]$] 2=C625J A=2?ED 7@C 2== AFCA@D6D] %92E DFC86 :? 56>2?5[ E96 2FE9@CD 4@?4=F565[ H@F=5 AFD9 FA 7@@5 AC:46D 2?5 H@CD6? 9F?86C]k^Am

kAm$6449: 42==D E92E D46?2C:@ 2 4=:>2E6 2?5 =2?5\FD6 “5:D2DE6C]” {2C86\D42=6 FD6 @7 6E92?@=\32D65 2G:2E:@? 7F6=[ D96 D2:5[ H@F=5 >62? 4=62C:?8 6G6? >@C6 =2?5 2?5 A@FC:?8 @? 6G6? >@C6 ?:EC@86? 76CE:=:K6C[ 5C:G:?8 FA 8C66?9@FD6 82D 6>:DD:@?D]k^Am

kAm“%96 C6DF=E[” D96 D2:5[ “H@F=5 36 6DD6?E:2==J E@ 6?D9C:?6 E9:D 5JD7F?4E:@?2= DJDE6> E92E H6 4C62E65]”k^Am

kAmk6>mr@\AF3=:D965 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E968F2C5:2?]4@>^6?G:C@?>6?E^a_ad^564^_b^6?G:C@?>6?E\4@C?\72C>:?8\ECF>A\25>:?:DEC2E:@?nC67l7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8Qmk6>m%96 vF2C5:2?k^6>mk^2mk6>m]k^6>mk^Am

kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8^Qmk6>mu=@@5=:89Ek^6>mk^2m k6>m:D 2 ?@?AC@7:E ?6HDC@@> E92E :?G6DE:82E6D E96 A@H6CD DE2==:?8 4=:>2E6 24E:@?]k^6>mk^Am

kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8^4@C?\6E92?@=\4=62?\6?6C8J\GD\4=:>2E6\4@DED^Qmk6>m%9:D DE@CJk^6>mk^2m k6>mH2D AC@5F465 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]7=@@5=:89E?6HD]@C8Qmk6>mu=@@5=:89Ek^6>mk^2m k6>m2?5 C6G:6H65 2?5 5:DEC:3FE65 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9F3D]=2^"_b<=8$#_Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQmk6>m$E24<6Ck^6>mk^2m]k^Am