CONCORD — In a 3-1 decision, the N.H. Supreme Court upheld a Superior Court decision dismissing a lawsuit filed by the mother of a Manchester public school student claiming the school district’s policy governing information on transgender and gender non-conforming students violated her constitutional rights to parent her child.
The court found the lower court, in dismissing the case, did not err in finding the policy did not violate the mother’s constitutional rights under the state and federal constitutions, and based its decision on the state constitution with guidance from federal cases.
kAmq@E9 E96 9:89 2?5 =@H6C 4@FCE CF=:?8D[ H9:=6 C6DA64E:?8 A2C6?E2= C:89ED E@ C2:D6 2?5 42C6 7@C E96:C 49:=5C6? :?4=F5:?8 :? 2 AF3=:4 D49@@=[ D2J :D :E ?@E 2? F?BF2=:7:65 C:89E[ 2?5 :?5:42E6 2 D49@@= A@=:4J @? EC2?D86?56C @C 86?56C ?@?4@?7@C>:?8 DEF56?ED 2?5 H92E :?7@C>2E:@? >2J 36 D92C65[ 5@6D ?@E C:D6 E@ E96 =6G6= @7 :?E6C76C:?8 H:E9 E9@D6 C:89ED]k^Am
kAmr9:67 yFDE:46 v@C5@? |24s@?2=5 ?@E65 E92E E96 DE2E6 92D =:EE=6 42D6 =2H 8@G6C?:?8 E96 4@?E6IE @7 A2C6?E2= C:89ED :? 2 D49@@= D6EE:?8[ H:E9 >@DE A2C6?E2= C:89ED 42D6D :?G@=G:?8 4FDE@5J @C 8F2C5:2?D9:AD[ 2D H6== 2D C6>@G:?8 49:=5C6? 7C@> E96:C A2C6?ED[ H9:49 2== :?G@=G6 D:8?:7:42?E 5F6 AC@46DD 4@?E6?E:@?D]k^Am
kAm%96 4@FCE CF=:?8 :D ?@E H92E 25G@42E6D @7 A2C6?E2= C:89ED 3:==D AC@A@D65 :? E96 =68:D=2EFC6 E96 A2DE 76H D6DD:@?D H@F=5 H2?E]k^Am
kAm%9@D6 3:==D[ :?4=F5:?8 D6G6C2= E9:D A2DE D6DD:@? E92E EC:65 E@ A2DD A:646>62= H92E H2D :? EH@ A2C6?E2= C:89ED 3:==D E92E 72:=65 =2DE J62C 2?5 E9:D J62C[ 5:5 ?@E 364@>6 =2H]k^Am
kAmx? 9:D CF=:?8[ |24s@?2=5 6?4@FC2865 7FEFC6 42D6D E@ 255C6DD E96 5F6 AC@46DD C:89ED :DDF6 C6=2E65 E@ D:>:=2C D49@@= A@=:4:6D E@ 2CC:G6 2E 2 4=62C6C =682= DE2?52C5]k^Am
kAm%96 4@FCED D2J A2C6?ED 92G6 >2?J @AE:@?D :7 E96J 5@ ?@E 28C66 H:E9 2 D49@@= 5:DEC:4E A@=:4J :?E6?565 E@ AC@E64E GF=?6C23=6 49:=5C6? 36D:56D 3C:?8:?8 =2HDF:ED E92E 5@ ?@E C:D6 E@ E96 =6G6= @7 4@?DE:EFE:@?2= 24E:@?] ~E96C 2G6?F6D @A6? E@ A2C6?ED E@ =62C? :7 E96:C 49:=5C6? 2C6 EC2?D:E:@?:?8 E@ 2?@E96C 86?56C[ :?4=F5:?8 E2=<:?8 E@ E96>]k^Am
kAm$FA6C:@C r@FCE yF586 p>J |6DD6C HC@E6 :? 96C CF=:?8 E92E E96 D49@@=’D A@=:4J “5@6D ?@E AC6G6?E A2C6?ED 7C@> @3D6CG:?8 E96:C 49:=5C6?’D 3692G:@C[ >@@5D[ 2?5 24E:G:E:6Dj E2=<:?8 E@ E96:C 49:=5C6?j AC@G:5:?8 C6=:8:@FD @C @E96C 65F42E:@? E@ E96:C 49:=5C6?j 49@@D:?8 H96C6 E96:C 49:=5C6? =:G6 2?5 8@ E@ D49@@=j @3E2:?:?8 >65:42= 42C6 2?5 4@F?D6=:?8 7@C E96:C 49:=5C6?j >@?:E@C:?8 E96:C 49:=5C6?’D 4@>>F?:42E:@?D @? D@4:2= >65:2j 49@@D:?8 H:E9 H9@> E96:C 49:=5C6? >2J D@4:2=:K6j 2?5 564:5:?8 H92E E96:C 49:=5C6? >2J 5@ :? E96:C 7C66 E:>6] x? D9@CE[ E96 !@=:4J A=246D ?@ =:>:ED @? E96 A=2:?E:77’D 23:=:EJ E@ A2C6?E 96C 49:=5 2D D96 D66D 7:E]”k^Am
kAmw6C @3D6CG2E:@? C67=64ED 2 &]$] $:IE9 r:C4F:E r@FCE @7 pAA62=D CF=:?8 :? #F?J@? G] |4rC2CJ[ caf &]$] `e_[ `ff W`hfeXX[ E92E H2D 4:E65 3J |24s@?2=5 :? E96 DE2E6 $FAC6>6 r@FCE’D CF=:?8]k^Am
kAm%96 7656C2= 4@FCE HC@E6 E92E “H9:=6 A2C6?ED >2J 92G6 2 7F?52>6?E2= C:89E E@ 564:56 H96E96C E@ D6?5 E96:C 49:=5 E@ 2 AF3=:4 D49@@=[ E96J 5@ ?@E 92G6 2 7F?52>6?E2= C:89E 86?6C2==J E@ 5:C64E 9@H 2 AF3=:4 D49@@= E62496D E96:C 49:=5] (96E96C :E :D E96 D49@@= 4FCC:4F=F>[ E96 9@FCD @7 E96 D49@@= 52J[ D49@@= 5:D4:A=:?6[ E96 E:>:?8 2?5 4@?E6?E @7 6I2>:?2E:@?D[ E96 :?5:G:5F2=D 9:C65 E@ E6249 2E E96 D49@@=[ E96 6IEC24FCC:4F=2C 24E:G:E:6D @776C65 2E E96 D49@@= @C[ 2D 96C6[ 2 5C6DD 4@56[ E96D6 :DDF6D @7 AF3=:4 65F42E:@? 2C6 86?6C2==J ‘4@>>:EE65 E@ E96 4@?EC@= @7 DE2E6 2?5 =@42= 2FE9@C:E:6D]”k^Am
kAm|2?J @7 E@52J’D #6AF3=:42?D :? E96 w@FD6 2?5 $6?2E6 92G6 EC:65 E@ 8:G6 A2C6?ED 4@?EC@= @7 E9@D6 E9:?8D :?4=F5:?8 4FCC:4F=F> 2?5 65F42E:@?2= >2E6C:2=D]k^Am
kAm%96 A@=:4J 2E :DDF6 :? y2?6 s@6 G] |2?496DE6C $49@@= s:DEC:4E H2D 25@AE65 3J E96 |2?496DE6C q@2C5 @7 $49@@= r@>>:EE66 :? u63CF2CJ a_a` 2?5 C6G:D65 E@ D2J E96 5:DEC:4E “D9@F=5 ?@E” :?DE625 @7 “D92== ?@E” C6G62= :?7@C>2E:@? C6G62=:?8 2 DEF56?E’D 86?56C DE2EFD @C 86?56C ?@?4@?7@C>:?8 AC6D6?E2E:@? E@ @E96CD F?=6DD =682==J C6BF:C65 E@ 5@ D@[” 3FE 5@6D ?@E 5:C64E=J ?2>6 A2C6?ED :? E96 AC@9:3:E:@?[ H9:49 :E 5:5 @C:8:?2==J]k^Am
kAm%96 >@E96C 925 4=2:>65 E96 A@=:4J G:@=2E65 !2CE `[ pCE:4=6 a @7 E96 DE2E6 4@?DE:EFE:@?[ @C E96 DE2E6’D q:== @C #:89ED[ 2?5 E96 u2>:=J t5F42E:@?2= #:89ED 2?5 !C:G24J p4E[ 2?5 E96 7656C2= !C@E64E:@? @7 !FA:= #:89ED p4E]k^Am
kAmx? 5:D>:DD:?8 E96 DF:E[ |6DD6C 7@F?5 E96 A@=:4J 5:5 ?@E :?7C:?86 FA@? 2 7F?52>6?E2= C:89E[ D@ 2 DEC:4E D4CFE:?J C6G:6H WE96 9:896DE 32CX H2D ?@E H2CC2?E65[ 2?5 F?56C E96 C2E:@?2= 32D:D E6DE W2 =@H6C 32CX[ :E 5:5 ?@E G:@=2E6 E96 4@?DE:EFE:@?]k^Am
kAm%96 :DDF6 367@C6 E96 $FAC6>6 r@FCE H2D H96E96C E96 DFA6C:@C 4@FCE 6CC65 :? 5:D>:DD:?8 E96 u:CDE p>6?5>6?E 4@>A=2:?E 56DA:E6 E96 2==682E:@? E96 A@=:4J 6?4@FC286D D49@@= @77:4:2=D E@ 4@?462= 96C 49:=5’D @A6? 2?5 AF3=:4 86?56C :56?E:EJ EC2?D:E:@? :? D49@@= 7C@> E96 >@E96C]k^Am
kAm%96 >@E96C =62C?65 @7 96C 49:=5’D EC2?D:E:@? 2?5 C6BF6DE E@ 36 42==65 3J 2 5:776C6?E ?2>6 2?5 AC@?@F?D E92E C67=64E65 2?@E96C 86?56C :?25G6CE6?E=J 7C@> @?6 @7 E96 49:=5’D E62496CD]k^Am
kAm%96 >@E96C 2D<65 E92E E96 D49@@= 255C6DD 96C 49:=5 2?5 FD6 E96 AC@?@F?D @7 E96 49:=5’D 3:CE9 86?56C[ 2?5 E62496CD 28C665 E@ 5@ E92E[ 3FE =2E6C E96 D49@@= AC:?4:A2= HC@E6 2 =6EE6C D2J:?8 D49@@= A@=:4J AC6G6?ED DE277 7C@> 5@:?8 E92E :7 E96 49:=5 C6BF6DED :E]k^Am
kAmp7E6C 2 5:D4FDD:@? H:E9 96C 49:=5[ E96 49:=5 2D<65 E@ 36 42==65 3J 96C @C:8:?2= ?2>6 2?5 AC@?@F?D[ H9:49 H2D C6DA64E65 3J E96 D49@@=[ E96 >@E96C 7:=65 E96 DF:E 4@?E6?5:?8 E96 A@=:4J >62?D D96 42??@E <?@H :7 E96 D49@@=’D 2?5 96C 49:=5’D 4@?E6?E:@? :D 724EF2==J ECF6 @C :7 E96J 2C6 7@==@H:?8 E96 A@=:4J 3J >:D=625:?8 96C]k^Am
kAmx? 255C6DD:?8 E96 2AA62= |24s@?2=5 HC:E6D[ “%96 BF6DE:@?D E9FD 364@>6 H92E :D E96 D4@A6 @7 E96 7F?52>6?E2= C:89E E@ A2C6?E 2?5 9@H 5@6D E96 !@=:4J :>A=:42E6 :E]”k^Am
kAmw6 2?DH6C65 E92E BF6DE:@? =2E6C :? 9:D @A:?:@?]k^Am
kAm“(6 42??@E 4@?4=F56 E92E 2?J :?E6C76C6?46 H:E9 A2C6?E2= C:89ED H9:49 >2J C6DF=E 7C@> ?@?\5:D4=@DFC6 :D @7 4@?DE:EFE:@?2= 5:>6?D:@?] %9:D A@E6?E:2= :?E6C76C6?46 DE2?5D :? DE2C< 4@?EC2DE[ 7@C 6I2>A=6[ E@ 4:C4F>DE2?46D :? H9:49 H6 92G6 7@F?5 E96 C:89E E@ A2C6?E :>A=:42E65 H96C6 A2C6?E2= 4FDE@5J H2D :? ;6@A2C5J[” |24s@?2=5 HC:E6D]k^Am
kAm(9:=6 E9C66 @7 E96 ;FDE:46D 28C665[ E96 A@=:4J 5@6D ?@E :?7C:?86 @? E96 7F?52>6?E2= C:89E E@ A2C6?E[ E96 ?6H6DE $FAC6>6 r@FCE yFDE:46[ |6=:DD2 q] r@F?EH2J[ 5:DD6?E65 D2J:?8 E96 A@=:4J 5@6D 4@?7=:4E E96 7F?52>6?E2= C:89E E@ A2C6?E 4:E:?8 D6G6C2= 564:D:@?D 7@C 7656C2= 5:DEC:4E 4@FCED]k^Am
kAmqFE |24s@?2=5 ?@E65[ “(6 36=:6G6 E96D6 42D6D 2C6 :?2AAC@AC:2E6 E@ @FC E2D< @7 C6D@=G:?8 H96E96C E9:D A2CE:4F=2C A@=:4J :D :? 4@?7=:4E H:E9 E96 }6H w2>AD9:C6 r@?DE:EFE:@?] x? 2?J 6G6?E[ H6 C6DA64E7F==J ?@E6 E92E E96C6 2AA62C E@ 36 5:776C6?46D 2>@?8 7656C2= 5:DEC:4E 4@FCED :? 255C6DD:?8 42D6D DF49 2D E9:D]”k^Am
kAm%96 9:89 4@FCE’D b\` 564:D:@? 42>6 H:E9@FE :?AFE 7C@> yFDE:46 p??2 q2C32C2 w2?EK |2C4@?:[ H9@ H2D C646?E=J AFE @? A2:5 25>:?:DEC2E:G6 =62G6]k^Am
(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.