In 1996, a school district in Milford, New York, barred a Christian children’s organization from using its facilities after school. The school contended that the club’s plans to pray, teach the Bible, and study scripture violated its prohibitions on religious worship.
But the U.S. Supreme Court disagreed. Because the school allowed other groups to use those same facilities, its prohibition of the club had specifically discriminated against its viewpoints, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote in the 2001, 6-3 ruling of Good News Club v. Milford Central School.
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm%9:D H66<[ 2 7656C2= 4@FCE 2AA=:65 2 D:>:=2C E6DE E@ 2? 6>@E:@?2= }6H w2>AD9:C6 DE2?5@77i E96 q@H $49@@= s:DEC:4E’D 564:D:@? E@ C6>@G6 D6G6C2= A2C6?ED 7C@> 2 9:89 D49@@= D@446C 82>6 2?5 32? E96> 7C@> 7FEFC6 82>6D 7@C AC@E6DE:?8 2 EC2?D86?56C 76>2=6 2E9=6E6] k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQmx?k^DA2?m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^?6H92>AD9:C63F==6E:?]4@>^HA\4@?E6?E^FA=@25D^a_ae^_g^u6==6CD\G\z6==6J\`DE\r:C4F:E\CF=:?8]A57QmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm2 CF=:?8 (65?6D52Jk^DA2?mk^2mkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm[ E96 `DE r:C4F:E r@FCE @7 pAA62=D D:565 H:E9 E96 A2C6?ED[ >@G:?8 E@ @G6CEFC? 2 }6H w2>AD9:C6 4@FCE’D CF=:?8 2?5 7:?5 E92E q@H 925 2=D@ 6?82865 :? G:6HA@:?E 5:D4C:>:?2E:@? 3J AF?:D9:?8 A2C6?ED H62C:?8 HC:DE32?5D @AA@D:?8 EC2?D86?56C 76>2=6 2E9=6E6D 7C@> A2CE:4:A2E:?8 :? 8:C=D’ DA@CED] k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm“(9:=6 E96 D49@@= 5:DEC:4E >2J >2<6 AC65:4E:G6 ;F58>6?ED 23@FE H96E96C 5:DCFAE:@? >2J @44FC 2?5 ‘?665 ?@E 36 46CE2:? @7 :ED 7@C642DE[’ :E 42??@E FD6 E9@D6 AC@;64E:@?D E@ :>>65:2E6=J DFAAC6DD 2 A2DD:G6[ D:=6?E AC@E6DE E92E 5:5 ?@E :>A2:C 2?J @7 E96 =68:E:>2E6 D49@@= 25>:?:DEC2E:@? :?E6C6DED C64@8?:K65 3J E96 $FAC6>6 r@FCE[” HC@E6 yF586 $2?5C2 {J?49 :? E96 >2;@C:EJ @A:?:@?] k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQmp== E9C66 ;F586D CF=65 E@ @G6CEFC? 2 a_ad &]$] s:DEC:4E r@FCE @7 }6H w2>AD9:C6 CF=:?8 E92E D:565 H:E9 E96 D49@@= 5:DEC:4E[ 3FE @?6 4:C4F:E 4@FCE ;F586[ yF=:6 #:<6=>2?[ 5:D28C665 H:E9 E96 C62D@?D E96 >2;@C:EJ FD65 E@ 86E E@ :ED CF=:?8]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm%96 564:D:@? :D E96 =2E6DE =682= D6E324< 7@C EC2?D86?56C C:89ED 25G@42E6D] x? yF=J[ EH@ }6H w2>AD9:C6 EC2?D86?56C 76>2=6 2E9=6E6D H9@ 925 DF65 E@ DEC:<6 5@H? 2 a_ac DE2E6 =2H 32CC:?8 76>2=6 EC2?D86?56C 2E9=6E6D 7C@> 8:C=D’ DA@CED E62>D :? 8C256D d E@ `a H:E95C6H E96:C =2HDF:E[ 27E6C E96 $FAC6>6 r@FCE FA96=5 E96 4@?DE:EFE:@?2=:EJ @7 D:>:=2C =2HD :? x529@ 2?5 (6DE ':C8:?:2]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm%9:D H66<’D 564:D:@? 2=D@ 4@>6D 27E6C E96 {68:D=2EFC6 A2DD65 2 =2H E@ A2C6 324< 2 D49@@= 5:DEC:4E’D 23:=:EJ E@ :DDF6 ?@\EC6DA2DD @C56CD] k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^84]?9]8@G^3:==0DE2EFD^=6824J^3Da_`e^3:==%6IE]2DAInDJla_aeU2>Aj:5l`ghcU2>AjEIEu@C>2El9E>=Q E2C86ElQ03=2?<QmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQmw@FD6 q:== ``gck^DA2?mk^2mkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm[ H9:49 E2<6D 67764E ~4E] `g[ C6BF:C6D D49@@= 5:DEC:4ED 2?5 >F?:4:A2=:E:6D E@ @3E2:? E96 2AAC@G2= @7 E96:C 7F== 8@G6C?:?8 3@5J — DF49 2D E96:C D6=64E 3@2C5 @C D49@@= 3@2C5 — 367@C6 :DDF:?8 2 “?@\EC6DA2DD” @C56C 282:?DE 2 A6CD@?] (9:=6 v@G] z6==J pJ@EE6 G6E@65 E92E 3:==[ 42==:?8 :E “F?H@C<23=6” 7@C =@42= @77:4:2=D 2?5 A@=:46 56A2CE>6?ED[ E96 w@FD6 2?5 $6?2E6 @G6CEFC?65 E96 G6E@ ?62C=J F?2?:>@FD=J @? pF8] `h]k^DA2?mk^Am
k9a 4=2DDlQ65:E@C:2=$F3965Qmp C6>@G2= 2?5 E96? 2 32?k^9am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm%96 7656C2= =2HDF:E DE6>D 7C@> 2 492C865 52J 2E 2 D@446C 7:6=5 :? $6AE6>36C a_ac]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm%96 q@H w:89 $49@@= 76>2=6 D@446C E62> H2D A=2J:?8 !=J>@FE9 #68:@?2= w:89 $49@@=] !=J>@FE9’D E62> :?4=F565 !2C<6C %:CC6==[ 2 EC2?D86?56C 2E9=6E6 H9@ 925 @?=J 2 H66< 62C=:6C @3E2:?65 2 7656C2= 4@FCE :?;F?4E:@? E@ 36 6I6>AE65 7C@> }6H w2>AD9:C6’D ?6H =2H @? EC2?D86?56C 2E9=6E6D 2?5 36 2==@H65 E@ A=2J]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQmx? E96 H66<D 367@C6 E96 82>6[ D6G6C2= A2C6?ED 925 C624965 @FE E@ q@H $49@@= s:DEC:4E @77:4:2=D E@ G@:46 E96:C @AA@D:E:@? E@ EC2?D86?56C 8:C=D A=2J:?8 @? 8:C=D’ DA@CED E62>D[ H:E9 @?6[ zJ=6 u6==6CD[ 56D4C:3:?8 EC2?D86?56C DFAA@CE6CD 2D A2CE:4:A2?ED :? “2 >6?E2==J :== 4F=E]” p?@E96C A2C6?E[ p?E9@?J u@@E6[ :DDF65 2 A@DE @? u2463@@< E96 52J 367@C6 E96 82>6 C2:D:?8 D276EJ 4@?46C?D 23@FE 2 EC2?D86?56C 8:C= A=2J:?8 282:?DE E96 q@H E62> 2?5 42==:?8 7@C A2C6?ED E@ AC@E6DE 2E E96 82>6] k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQmw2G:?8 D66? E92E A@DE[ q@H $FA6C:?E6?56?E |2C4J z6==6J[ !C:?4:A2= |2EE u:D<[ 2?5 pE9=6E:4 s:C64E@C |:4926= s6D:=6ED 6IAC6DD65 4@?46C? E92E %:CC6== H@F=5 7246 92C2DD>6?E[ 2?5 2D<65 2 q@H !@=:46 s6A2CE>6?E =:6FE6?2?E E@ 2EE6?5 E96 82>6[ 244@C5:?8 E@ 4@FCE C64@C5D] %96J 2=D@ D6?E 2 ?@E6 E@ A2C6?ED FC8:?8 C6DEC2:?E] k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQmsFC:?8 E96 82>6[ E9C66 A2C6?ED 3682? H62C:?8 A:?< HC:DE32?5D H:E9 “))” HC:EE6? @? E96> 2?5 “}ps[” D9@CE 7@C 8@?25D[ >62?E E@ DJ>3@=:K6 @AA@D:E:@? E@ EC2?D86?56C A2CE:4:A2E:@? :? 8:C=D’ DA@CED] %96J H6C6 E@=5 E@ E2<6 E96 HC:DE32?5D @77 3J 3@E9 u:D< 2?5 E96 A@=:46 =:6FE6?2?E] (96? @?6 A2C6?E C67FD65[ D49@@= @77:4:2=D :?DECF4E65 E96 C676C66 E@ A2FD6 E96 82>6 F?E:= E96 HC:DE32?5D H6C6 C6>@G65] p== A2C6?ED 6G6?EF2==J 4@>A=:65 2?5 E96 82>6 C6DF>65[ 3FE D49@@= @77:4:2=D =2E6C @C56C65 u@@E6 E@ =62G6 D49@@= 8C@F?5D 27E6C 96 5:DA=2J65 2 A@DE6C DE2E:?8 “!C@E64E (@>6?’D $A@CED 7@C u6>2=6 pE9=6E6D]”k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm{2E6C[ E96 5:DEC:4E D6?E u6==6CD 2?5 u@@E6 ?@\EC6DA2DD @C56CD E92E AC6G6?E65 E96> 7C@> 6?E6C:?8 D49@@= 8C@F?5D @C 2EE6?5:?8 82>6D 7@C 2E =62DE 2 H66<[ E9@F89 E96 5:DEC:4E =2E6C 2==@H65 u6==6CD E@ 2EE6?5 D@446C 82>6D H9:=6 E96 7656C2= 4@FCE 4@?D:56C65 9:D =2HDF:E] u@@E6 2?5 u6==6CD 2C6 2>@?8 E96 7@FC A2C6?ED H9@ DF65] k^DA2?mk^Am
k9a 4=2DDlQ65:E@C:2=$F3965Qmp E6DE @7 E96 u:CDE p>6?5>6?Ek^9am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm%96 4:C4F:E 4@FCE 4@?7C@?E65 2 <6J u:CDE p>6?5>6?E E6DEi (2D E96 q@H $49@@= s:DEC:4E’D C6>@G2= 2?5 DF3D6BF6?E 32? @7 E96 A2C6?ED 7C@> DA@CED 82>6D 2 “DF3;64E >2EE6C C6DEC:4E:@?” @C “G:6HA@:?E 5:D4C:>:?2E:@?”nk^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm$A6649 C6DEC:4E:@?D 42? 36 =682= :7 E96J 2C6 DF3;64E >2EE6C C6DEC:4E:@?D[ >62?:?8 E96 32? :D 7@C 2 3C@25 E@A:4 @7 DA6649] %96 4@FCED >FDE DE:== 7:?5 DF49 2 32? C62D@?23=6]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQmw@H6G6C[ :7 E96 C6DEC:4E:@? 2AA62CD E@ E2C86E 2 DA64:7:4 G:6HA@:?E H:E9:? E92E E@A:4[ :E :D ?@E 4@?DE:EFE:@?2=[ E96 $FAC6>6 r@FCE 92D 96=5] k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQmv@G6C?>6?ED >2J 56A=@J DF49 C6DEC:4E:@?D @?=J E@ 2 “=:>:E65 AF3=:4 7@CF>[” DF49 2D 2? 6?4=@D65 D49@@= >66E:?8j :E >2J ?@E 86?6C2==J :>A@D6 DA6649 C6DEC:4E:@?D @G6C 2 “EC25:E:@?2= AF3=:4 7@CF>[” DF49 2D 2 A2C< @C D:56H2=<]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQmx? q@H’D 42D6[ {J?49 CF=65 E92E E96 5:DEC:4E’D 24E:@?D 4@?DE:EFE65 G:6HA@:?E 5:D4C:>:?2E:@?[ A@:?E:?8 E@ E96 D49@@= 5:DEC:4E @77:4:2=D’ E6DE:>@?J E92E E96 DJ>3@=D @? E96 A:?< HC:DE32?5D H6C6 “6I4=FD:@?2CJ” 2?5 “92E67F=]” %92E DF886DE65 E96 5:DEC:4E E@@< 24E:@? 282:?DE E96 A2C6?ED “3642FD6 :E 5:D28C665 H:E9 E96 AC@E6DE >6DD286 4@?G6J65[” {J?49 HC@E6] “%9:D H6?E 36J@?5 >6C6 4@?E6?E ?6FEC2=:EJ[” D96 25565]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm“%96 492C24E6C:DE:4D @7 E96 D49@@= 2D 2 A=246 @7 =62C?:?8 C6:?7@C46 E92E 25>:?:DEC2E@CD 42??@E 72G@C @?6 D:56 @7 2 5632E6 :?G@=G:?8 A2C6?E2= DA6649 @? 2? :DDF6 @7 AC@>:?6?E AF3=:4 4@?46C?[ 2?5 H9:49[ :? E9@D6 A2C6?ED’ G:6HD[ 4@?46C?65 E96 D276EJ @7 E96:C 49:=5C6?[” {J?49 HC@E6]k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm{J?49 ?@E65 E92E D49@@= 5:DEC:4ED 92G6 >@C6 =66H2J E@ C6DEC:4E DA6649 E92? @E96C 8@G6C?>6?E 3@5:6D :7 E96J AC65:4E :E H:== 42FD6 “>2E6C:2= 5:DCFAE:@?”j 7656C2= 4@FCED 92G6 FA96=5 D49@@= 564:D:@?D E@ 32? 4=@E9:?8 E92E 762EFC6D 2 r@?7656C2E6 7=28 E92E H@F=5 =:<6=J FAD6E DEF56?ED[ 7@C :?DE2?46] k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQmqFE D96 CF=65 E92E E96 5676?52?ED 925 ?@E AC@G65 E96 HC:DE32?5D 925 42FD65 2 >2E6C:2= 5:DCFAE:@?[ D:?46 E96 A2C6?ED 925 H@C? E96> BF:6E=J 2?5 D:?46 :E H2D ?@E 4=62C E92E 2?J A=2J6CD 925 ?@E:465 E96>] “pD 2AA6==2?ED 4@?4656[ 24E:@?D 3J D49@@= 25>:?:DEC2E@CD E@ :?E6CG6?6 E@ AC6G6?E 24EF2= 92C2DD>6?E H@F=5 36 A6C>:DD:3=6 F?56C E96 u:CDE p>6?5>6?E[” D96 HC@E6] $96 25565i “qFE 2AA6==2?ED’ D:=6?E 5:DA=2J @7 E96 ‘))’ DJ>3@= 2E E96 $6AE6>36C `f 82>6 76== D9@CE @7 92C2DD>6?E 2?5 5:DCFAE:@?]”k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm%96 @C56C D6?5D E96 42D6 324< E@ E96 5:DEC:4E 4@FCE :? }6H w2>AD9:C6[ H9:49 >FDE ?@H 564:56 2? 2AAC@AC:2E6 C6>65J] qFE E96 CF=:?8 :>A=:65 E96 =2H :? 7FEFC6 42D6D :D ?@E J6E D6EE=65] k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQmx? 96C 4@?4FCC6?46[ #:<6=>2? 28C665 E96C6 925 366? G:6HA@:?E 5:D4C:>:?2E:@?[ 3FE 4C:E:4:K65 E96 @E96C >2;@C:EJ @A:?:@? 7@C ?@E 2AA=J:?8 E96 6I:DE:?8 =682= E6DED >@C6 4=62C=J] $A64:7:42==J[ D96 ?@E65 E92E {J?49 49@D6 ?@E E@ A:4< 36EH66? E96 EH@ 4@>>@?=J FD65 E6DED — E96 =:>:E65 AF3=:4 7@CF> E6DE @C 2 3C@256C E6DE E92E 2AA=:6D E@ D49@@=D DA64:7:42==J <?@H? 2D %:?<6C] #2E96C[ #:<6=>2? ?@E65[ {J?49’D 564:D:@? C6=:6D @? ?6:E96C E6DE] k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQmtIA=2:?:?8 E92E 564:D:@?[ {J?49 HC@E6 E92E ?6:E96C E6DE H2D 2 “A6C764E 7:E 7@C E9:D AF3=:4 9:89 D49@@= DA6649 42D6[ 2?5 H6 ?@E6 E92E E96 $FAC6>6 r@FCE 92D ?@E 255C6DD65 E9:D AC64:D6 BF6DE:@?]”k^DA2?mk^Am
k9a 4=2DDlQ65:E@C:2=$F3965Qm}6H DE2E6 =2Hk^9am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm%96 A2DD286 @7 wq ``gc H:== =:<6=J =:>:E 7FEFC6 D49@@= 5:DEC:4ED’ FD286 @7 ?@\EC6DA2DD @C56CD] k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm%96 ?6H =2H C6BF:C6D 2 7F== D49@@= 3@2C5 @C D6=64E 3@2C5 G@E6 367@C6 ?@\EC6DA2DD @C56CD 42? 36 :DDF65[ 2?5 C6BF:C6D E92E E96 @C56C 36 :DDF65 E@ AC@E64E AF3=:4 D276EJ @C AC6G6?E DF3DE2?E:2= 5:DCFAE:@? @C AC@A6CEJ 52>286] p7E6C bd 52JD[ E96 =2H C6BF:C6D E96 8@G6C?:?8 3@5J E@ E2<6 2 ?6H G@E6 :7 :E H2?ED E@ 6IE6?5 E96 ?@\EC6DA2DD @C56C[ 2?5 =:>:ED 2?J @C56C E@ @?6 J62C] k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm%96 =2H 2=D@ 2==@HD 2 A6CD@? H9@ :D :DDF65 2? @C56C E@ C6BF6DE 2 962C:?8 367@C6 E96 8@G6C?:?8 3@5J E@ 4@?E6DE E96 @C56C[ 2?5 E@ 2AA62= 2 ?682E:G6 C6DF=E E@ 2 DFA6C:@C 4@FCE] k^DA2?mk^Am
kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei c__jQm“%9:D :D ECJ:?8 E@ 32=2?46 3@E9 2? :DDF6 H96C6 J@F ?665 E@ E9C@H D@>63@5J @FE @7 2 3F:=5:?8 H:E9 E96 4:E:K6?D’ C:89E E@ 36 23=6 E@ FD6 AF3=:4 724:=:E:6D[” $6?] %:> {2?8[ 2 $2?3@C?E@? #6AF3=:42?[ D2:5 :? 2 DA6649 367@C6 E96 G6E@ @G6CC:56] k^DA2?mk^Am
(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.