This month, Maine’s Law Court upheld the incarceration of a teenager known as JR for low-level property crimes.
In a concurring opinion issued with the decision, Chief Justice Leigh Saufley and two of her colleagues indicated they supported his incarceration, but said the lack of resourced alternatives that supposedly left the state with no other options was a “tragedy.”
kAm%96 k6>m!@CE=2?5 !C6DD w6C2=5k^6>m 42==65 E96 @A:?:@? “D42E9:?8” 2?5 k6>mq2?8@C s2:=J }6HDk^6>m 2 “D92CA 4C:E:BF6]” qFE 4@?D:56C:?8 E96 9@CC@CD @7 {@?8 rC66< *@FE9 s6G6=@A>6?E r6?E6C 2C6 D@ H6== 5@4F>6?E65[ DF49 C96E@C:4 7C@> E96 DE2E6’D 9:896DE 4@FCE :D E96 =62DE @?6 D9@F=5 6IA64E] ':6H65 =6DD 492C:E23=J[ E96 4@FCE :D A2DD:?8 E96 3F4< H96? :E 925 E96 @AA@CEF?:EJ E@ :?DE:82E6 492?86]k^Am
kAm“(6 <?@H E92E 49:=5C6? H9@ 4@>>:E =@H\=6G6= AC@A6CEJ 4C:>6D 2C6 ?@E C:D< E@ AF3=:4 D276EJ[” D2:5 y#’D 2AA6==2E6 2EE@C?6J %:?2 w62E96C }2562F :? 2? :?E6CG:6H H:E9 k6>m%96 !9@6?:Ik^6>m] “p?J 36?67:E H6 86E 7C@> :?42C46C2E:?8 E96> :D 4@>A=6E6=J @3=:E6C2E65 3J E96 56G2DE2E:@? E92E 3C:?8D E@ E92E 49:=5 2?5 8@:?8 :?E@ E96 7FEFC6 2D 25F=ED] w@H 5@ H6 42== D@>6E9:?8 2 EC2865J 2?5 2==@H :E E@ 4@?E:?F6n”k^Am
kAmx? E96 @A:?:@?[ $2F7=6J 3@F89E E96 DE2E6’D 2C8F>6?E E92E 2 `d\J62C\@=5’D 72:=FC6 E@ :>>65:2E6=J 56D:DE 7C@> >:D3692G:@C 2?5 DF3>:E E@ 4@F?D6=:?8 @G6C @776?D6D DF49 2D A2:?E:?8 “ca_” @? 2 DE@=6? D4@@E6C 2?5 E9C@H:?8 C@4<D 2E 2 D49@@= >62?E 96 H2D “DA:C2=:?8 @FE @7 4@?EC@=]” %96J 28C665 H:E9 AC@D64FE@CD E92E AC@32E:@? “H@F=5 2=>@DE 46CE2:?=J 72:=” 2?5 E92E y# A@D65 DF49 2 8C2G6 E9C62E E@ E96 4@>>F?:EJ E92E :E @FEH6:8965 E96 D6C:@FD =@?8\E6C> 92C>D @7 ;FG6?:=6 56E6?E:@?]k^Am
kAmx? @C2= 2C8F>6?ED[ $2F7=6J D2:5 E96C6 H2D “D@>6E9:?8 23@FE :?42C46C2E:@? E92E 42? C62==J 7@4FD E96 >:?5]” *6E E96 DE2E6 5:5?’E D66> E96 =62DE 3:E :?E6C6DE65 :? E6DE:?8 E92E 9JA@E96D:D :? E96 >@>6?Ei y# H2D 2=C625J =@4<65 FA 7@C `_ 52JD 2E |@F?E2:?G:6H *@FE9 s6G6=@A>6?E r6?E6C 367@C6 EC:2= 2?5 96 H2D 2AA62=:?8 9:D 42D6 7C@> {@?8 rC66<]k^Am
kAm“}@ @?6 2D<65 9:> @? E96 C64@C5 H92E 5:5 E92E 5@[ H92E 5:5 E92E >62? E@ 9:>n” }2562F D2:5] “(2D 96 2H2C6 9@H D6C:@FD E9:D H2D ?@H 2?5 H@F=5 96 36 H:==:?8 E@ ECJ 92C56Cn %96C6 H2D ?@ 4@?G6CD2E:@? H:E9 9:> 23@FE H92E E9@D6 `_ 52JD 5:5]”k^Am
kAmx?5665[ y#’D G@:46 5@6D?’E 2AA62C @? E96 C64@C5 7C@> 9:D EC:2=] %96 @?=J A6CD@? 25G@42E:?8 282:?DE :?42C46C2E:@? :D 9:D >@E96C]k^Am
kAmx? =:89E @7 E9:D[ E96 ;F5:4:2CJ’D 2AAC@G2= @7 DF49 92CD9 2?5 56EC:>6?E2= EC62E>6?E @7 2 E66?286C D9@F=5 5F== $2F7=6J’D “D92CA 4C:E:BF6” :? E96 6J6D @7 E96 AF3=:4]k^Am
kAm“x 2AAC64:2E6 96C D6?E:>6?ED 2?5 x 5@ 28C66 E96 {68:D=2EFC6 ?665D E@ 86E :?G@=G65] x 5@ 28C66 ,E92E. E96 6I64FE:G6 3C2?49 G:2 E96 8@G6C?@C[ G:2 w62=E9 2?5 wF>2? $6CG:46D[ G:2 E96 s6A2CE>6?E @7 r@CC64E:@?D[ ?665D E@ 86E :?G@=G65] qFE E96 ;F5:4:2CJ 92D E@ 86E :?G@=G65 E@@[” }2562F 2C8F65]k^Am
kAm!@:?E:?8 @FE E92E $2F7=6J :D @G6CD66:?8 2 DJDE6> E92E “EC28:42==J :D :?42C46C2E:?8 2?5 AF?:D9:?8 2?5 9FCE:?8 49:=5C6? H9@ D9@F=5 ?6G6C 36 :?G@=G65 :? E92E A2CE @7 E96 DJDE6>[ 6G6C[” }2562F D2:5 E96 ;FDE:46D “C62==J 925 E96 @AA@CEF?:EJ 96C6 E@ 5C2H 2 =:?6 :? E96 D2?5 2?5 D2J[ C682C5=6DD @7 E96 2G2:=23:=:EJ @7 C6D@FC46D[ ,E92E. E96 :?42C46C2E:@? @7 49:=5C6? 7@C E96D6 EJA6D @7 @776?D6D :D :?2AAC@AC:2E6 2?5 :E 5@6D ?@E DBF2C6 H:E9 @FC ;FG6?:=6 4@56]”k^Am
kAm“x’> @?6 2EE@C?6J H:E9 @?6 4=:6?E H9@ :D 4@>A=6E6=J 56A6?56?E FA@? E96 A@H6CD E92E 36 E@ 8:G6 >6 E96 ?@5] %92EVD @?6 E9:?8] $96 k6>m:Dk^6>m E96 A@H6C E92E 36]” }2562F D2:5] “$96’D E96 49:67 @7 2 4@\6BF2= 3C2?49 @7 8@G6C?>6?E] $96 :D 6BF2= E@ E96 8@G6C?@C[ E@ E96 DA62<6C @7 E96 9@FD6 2?5 E96 D6?2E6 AC6D:56?E] $96 :D 6BF2= E@ E96>] $96 92D 2FE9@C:EJ]”k^Am
kAmtG6? D@[ @?=J EH@ @E96C ;FDE:46D D:8?65 @? E@ $2F7=6J’D 4C:E:4:D>D @7 E96 DJDE6>]k^Am
kAm“%96 @E96C 7@FC ,;FDE:46D. 5@?’E D66 E9:D 2D 2 AC@3=6>n qFD:?6DD 2D FDF2= :D 2446AE23=6 E@ E96>n x 7:?5 E92E 2AA2==:?8[” }2562F 564=2C65] “pE =62DE E9@D6 E9C66 ;FDE:46D 2C6 24<?@H=658:?8 E92E E96 DJDE6> :D ?@E 7=2H65[ :E’D 3C@<6?[ 2?5 :E’D 9FCE:?8 E96 >@DE GF=?6C23=6 49:=5C6? :? @FC DE2E6] !6@A=6 E92E E96 DE2E6 92D E2<6? 4FDE@5J @7[ E96J 2C6 C6DA@?D:3=6 7@C E96D6 49:=5C6? 2?5 H6 2C6 @G6CD66:?8 E96:C 56DECF4E:@? :? E96 ?2>6 @7 C6923:=:E2E:@?]”k^Am
kAm“x7 E96 =2H 4@FCE 925 D2:5 ?@ E@ E9:D[ E92E H@F=5 92G6 D6?E 2 >F49 3:886C >6DD286 E92? ‘E9:D :D 2 EC2865J[ 3FE 3FD:?6DD 4@?E:?F6D 2D FDF2=[’” }2562F D2:5] “%96J’C6 @G6CD66:?8 2?5 2FE9@C:K:?8 2 EC2865J E9C@F89 @FC DJDE6>] xE’D 4C2KJ]”k^Am
