The editors need to be more discriminating in the letters they print if they are to avoid simply repeating falsehoods and innuendo-filled misleading statements. For example, the letter from Finley Walsh.
Unfortunately, in this day and age, we have become extremely mistrustful of what we are told by the government, including politicians and bureaucrats.
From what I've read, Gov. Walz was a non-commissioned officer in the National Guard. If the facts are as this letter states, Walz submitted his retirement papers just before his unit got its orders to deploy and just a few months before they did deploy. As one of the unit's leaders, how much notice did Walz get before the official orders were delivered? Was it days...weeks...or months?
Would Walz have a reason to leave before deployment? Of course he would. Who wants to get sent to Iraq for an indeterminate period of time? So it is possible that when the rumors started, Walz found a way out. And I'm sure deployments are not unforeseen circumstances by those who serve in this role.
No one knows what was in Walz' mind but Walz and his fellow soldiers. But Walz' rank was lowered when he retired which sounds like a form of punishment. Perhaps his superiors were upset at Walz' convenient retirement timing.
After 24 years, Walz could have delayed his retirement to be his unit's leader in a combat theater.
By falsely insinuating that he served in combat, Walz was gilding his lily to embellish his service record. No one would criticize him for not being in combat, but he shouldn't lie about it. I have read at least three accounts of either falsely claiming a combat role, or having others falsely claim it for him and he did not correct the public record.
The point of this lengthy rebuttal is that one person's truth is another's falsehood. These issues are rarely cut and dry. People who do wrong will never admit it and often cover their tracks. Even when caught, they deny culpability. Look at Sen. Bob Menendez as an example. Even his gold bars were explained away even though the evidence was clear. Democrats in the Senate did not move to expel him because it might have upset their hold on power. Some things are more important than the truth.
If there is speech with which you disagree, you should work hard to publish your version (as this letter does.) Calling for censorship is not the answer. How did censorship work out when the media refused to publish information on Hunter Biden's laptop because it was labeled Russian disinformation by 51 former or current intelligence officials?
Unfortunately, in this day and age, we have people who refuse to admit the facts, and continue to parrot lies even after they're proven to be lies or conspiracy theories. You know, people like you G. While I don't support censorship, people like you that keep writing nonsense after it's proven to be nonsense because they're brainwashed by a cult detract from productive discussion.
Again I ask, if you're so upset at these silly rumors (that Neath painstakingly explained to you multiple times), how do you continue to support a five time draft dodger whose supposed physical limitations never existed?
I'm sure Neath will explain in detail how ranks are handled when someone retires, but stop inventing new idiotic claims to try to discredit Walz, and railing about people lying when you support a draft dodger who's the biggest liar we've ever seen on the American political scene, it makes you sound like an idiot.
Not sure if Lisa Braiterman will read these comments but great "letter to the editor" Lisa. I don't agree with censorship but I get your sentiment as I tried to point out to the Sun that it should contain disclaimers about their "letters" section. No where on this online format or the print version is there any disclaimer or notation that the "opinion, *facts*, ideas, and values" written in these submissions are not vetted or fact checked by The Conway Daily Sun, or that the organization doesn’t share the same opinions.
The simplest thing the Sun could do is change the section title of "letters" to the word "OPINIONS" and perhaps print it in red like the NY Times does.
One of the worse parts about folks like G_Allen is they put out so much mis and disinformation that a person just doesn’t even know where to start with a rebuttal.
Also, it’s highly unlikely G_Allen or others who share his same echo chamber will read or hear your rebuttal anyways, so this response is for the folks who care to know the truth.
1. **As one of the unit's leaders, how much notice did Walz get before the official orders were delivered?** Walz would NOT have gotten any heads up about a potential deployment prior to the rest of the unit, regardless of his rank. The unit was put on NOTICE in March ’05 of a potential deployment within the next two years, not even necessarily a “Combat Deployment” only a deployment notice. Walz had already submitted his retirement package in February. (Bud, I can’t deep dive into the minutiae of how the National Guard works versus the regular Army but please understand it’s very different, their deployment rotations are different, it’s complicated. Just know this, Guard units often times get blindsided by rapid deployments, even the commanding officers know only weeks out, especially at the height of the wars.)
2. **Was it days...weeks...or months?** The timing question is irrelevant because as I pointed out he wouldn’t have known anything earlier than others. Folks retire, finish their contracts, rotate to other units all the time. We don’t have a list of who else was in and out of this unit during the time but rest assured there were plenty.
3. **Would Walz have a reason to leave before deployment? Of course he would. Who wants to get sent to Iraq for an indeterminate period of time? ** With this question, that you answered yourself so confidently, It’s obvious you never served. If you had served, especially during these conflicts you’d know something. We all wanted to go! Were we scared? Hell yeah, but when the call comes you want to go defend the men & women you have been training alongside of for months, sometimes years. When you train to fight, like mortar units do, you want to go fight. I’m not saying it’s good or bad, that’s just how it is. This is what you signed up for and it’s an honor to serve in that capacity. That being said if you’ve done 2+ decades of service, you’ve done your time combat or not. You don’t make it to E8 or E9 without some character and integrity, so I’m confident that if Tim Walz would have known prior to submitting his retirement package that his soldiers were going down range, to war, he would’ve most likely extended his contract. However, he had other service in mind, and when the deployment notice was given a month later they didn’t even know where the hell they might potentially go in the next 2 years. Should he have signed up for another 4 years (making 28 years in service) just to potentially deploy to Italy again? That’s insanity and just a stupid argument ignorant folks are making. Your “sure deployments are not unforeseen circumstances by those who serve in this role”? You know nothing about service G_Allen. Combat deployments, especially around the time of the surge (which this was) were absolutely unforeseen. You train and prepare but you don’t know where or when you are going in Guard and Reserve units. The only folks who get a hint of a timeline are those in units on active duty who rotate out with their counterpart (sister) units.
4. **But Walz' rank was lowered when he retired which sounds like a form of punishment. Perhaps his superiors were upset at Walz' convenient retirement timing.**. This right here is more evidence of you simply adding your feelings and opinions to the misinformation your chosen outlets are feeding you. Have you people never heard of positional authority or a role appointment? He was a Master Sergeant the command needed a Sergeant Major, they made him the guy. He wasn’t able to retire at that rank officially because he didn’t complete necessary correspondence for the rank (a lot of paperwork and correspondence in the military) and that’s that. Nothing to do with his units leadership or any repercussions to his retirement. #fullstop
5. **After 24 years, Walz could have delayed his retirement to be his unit's leader in a combat theater.**. He was already retired when they were ordered to Iraq in July ’05. You don’t just quit the military and you also don’t just “delay” retirement. That’s just not how it works G_Allen and such an asinine thing to say. Just say it out loud to yourself….”AFTER 24 YEAR, Walz COULD have delayed his retirement to be his unit’s leader…..” #fullstop
6. **falsely insinuating that he served in combat** We’ve went over this one already in a previous comment section. He boned up hard saying he carried a gun in war. We all screw up. He still trained as a war fighter and trained with those weapons, more than you and many of those shouting about it can say I’m sure. Share your “three accounts” or move on from this point you keep trying to make.
G_Allen if you are going to continue this nonsense for the love of humanity post your sources. You said, “from what I’ve read” and “I have read at least three accounts of….” Share them man!? If you are so confident that your sources are the truth, then share them with us. I doubt that you will because you showed your cards with the ridiculous statement that “one person’s truth is another’s falsehood”. What?
The opposite of fact is falsehood. A person who knows nothing is closer to the truth than someone whose mind is full of falsehoods and errors.
If this statement is your truth, then sir you are committed to your ignorance.
Truth is confirmed by inspection and delay; falsehood by haste and uncertainty.
Thanks for your service and your thoughtful reply to my post.
The point of my reply to Lisa Braiterman's letter was that "facts" are very debatable and subject to interpretation, and thus trying to label something as "factually inaccurate" when it is an opinion piece, published as a letter to the editor, is not going to be helpful. Everyone who has ever read a newspaper knows (or should know) that letters are from readers, they are meant to respond to things they read in the paper, and they are opinions. Letter writers can cite sources if they wish to make their argument more compelling but there is no ethical requirement to do so.
I did not write the original letter. This is not a topic I would want to spend more than five minutes on. I'd much rather discuss Gov. Walz' Far Left record as Governor, but even that isn't of much interest. We focus on the VP when the pick is made and during their debate, but otherwise most of our focus is on, and should be on, the top of the ticket.
As to my claim that Walz inflated his service record, I cannot give you any personal examples since I never served in the military. And I'm sure if I pointed you to a Fox News or other conservative source, you would say they can't be believed and you would still not be convinced.
And the subhead reads: "Four veterans who investigate claims of fraudulent military service said they do not believe the governor is guilty of “stolen valor,” but that he did misrepresent his record at times."
So if the NYT admits Gov. Walz misrepresented his record "at times" (not the plural of this word), then that settles the issue as far as I am concerned.
On the other main topic, here is a quote from Military.com which says that Walz could have known about his deployment before he retired. Perhaps you know more than the editors of Military.com, but this backs up my supposition:
"After serving in the National Guard for 24 years, Walz retired two months before his unit received official orders for a deployment to Iraq in 2005, though it's possible Walz could have known a deployment order was imminent because he was in a senior enlisted position."
I'm done with this topic, but I hope you can see that even if the sources I just quoted are wrong, trying to "fact check" letters to the editor would be a foolhardy endeavor and would lead to selective censorship. And that's exactly what happened in regards to the Hunter laptop story which was suppressed by the mainstream media and social media.
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd,
racist or sexually-oriented language. PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK. Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another
person will not be tolerated. Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone
or anything. Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism
that is degrading to another person. Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on
each comment to let us know of abusive posts. Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness
accounts, the history behind an article.
(4) comments
Unfortunately, in this day and age, we have become extremely mistrustful of what we are told by the government, including politicians and bureaucrats.
From what I've read, Gov. Walz was a non-commissioned officer in the National Guard. If the facts are as this letter states, Walz submitted his retirement papers just before his unit got its orders to deploy and just a few months before they did deploy. As one of the unit's leaders, how much notice did Walz get before the official orders were delivered? Was it days...weeks...or months?
Would Walz have a reason to leave before deployment? Of course he would. Who wants to get sent to Iraq for an indeterminate period of time? So it is possible that when the rumors started, Walz found a way out. And I'm sure deployments are not unforeseen circumstances by those who serve in this role.
No one knows what was in Walz' mind but Walz and his fellow soldiers. But Walz' rank was lowered when he retired which sounds like a form of punishment. Perhaps his superiors were upset at Walz' convenient retirement timing.
After 24 years, Walz could have delayed his retirement to be his unit's leader in a combat theater.
By falsely insinuating that he served in combat, Walz was gilding his lily to embellish his service record. No one would criticize him for not being in combat, but he shouldn't lie about it. I have read at least three accounts of either falsely claiming a combat role, or having others falsely claim it for him and he did not correct the public record.
The point of this lengthy rebuttal is that one person's truth is another's falsehood. These issues are rarely cut and dry. People who do wrong will never admit it and often cover their tracks. Even when caught, they deny culpability. Look at Sen. Bob Menendez as an example. Even his gold bars were explained away even though the evidence was clear. Democrats in the Senate did not move to expel him because it might have upset their hold on power. Some things are more important than the truth.
If there is speech with which you disagree, you should work hard to publish your version (as this letter does.) Calling for censorship is not the answer. How did censorship work out when the media refused to publish information on Hunter Biden's laptop because it was labeled Russian disinformation by 51 former or current intelligence officials?
Unfortunately, in this day and age, we have people who refuse to admit the facts, and continue to parrot lies even after they're proven to be lies or conspiracy theories. You know, people like you G. While I don't support censorship, people like you that keep writing nonsense after it's proven to be nonsense because they're brainwashed by a cult detract from productive discussion.
Again I ask, if you're so upset at these silly rumors (that Neath painstakingly explained to you multiple times), how do you continue to support a five time draft dodger whose supposed physical limitations never existed?
I'm sure Neath will explain in detail how ranks are handled when someone retires, but stop inventing new idiotic claims to try to discredit Walz, and railing about people lying when you support a draft dodger who's the biggest liar we've ever seen on the American political scene, it makes you sound like an idiot.
Not sure if Lisa Braiterman will read these comments but great "letter to the editor" Lisa. I don't agree with censorship but I get your sentiment as I tried to point out to the Sun that it should contain disclaimers about their "letters" section. No where on this online format or the print version is there any disclaimer or notation that the "opinion, *facts*, ideas, and values" written in these submissions are not vetted or fact checked by The Conway Daily Sun, or that the organization doesn’t share the same opinions.
The simplest thing the Sun could do is change the section title of "letters" to the word "OPINIONS" and perhaps print it in red like the NY Times does.
One of the worse parts about folks like G_Allen is they put out so much mis and disinformation that a person just doesn’t even know where to start with a rebuttal.
Also, it’s highly unlikely G_Allen or others who share his same echo chamber will read or hear your rebuttal anyways, so this response is for the folks who care to know the truth.
1. **As one of the unit's leaders, how much notice did Walz get before the official orders were delivered?** Walz would NOT have gotten any heads up about a potential deployment prior to the rest of the unit, regardless of his rank. The unit was put on NOTICE in March ’05 of a potential deployment within the next two years, not even necessarily a “Combat Deployment” only a deployment notice. Walz had already submitted his retirement package in February. (Bud, I can’t deep dive into the minutiae of how the National Guard works versus the regular Army but please understand it’s very different, their deployment rotations are different, it’s complicated. Just know this, Guard units often times get blindsided by rapid deployments, even the commanding officers know only weeks out, especially at the height of the wars.)
2. **Was it days...weeks...or months?** The timing question is irrelevant because as I pointed out he wouldn’t have known anything earlier than others. Folks retire, finish their contracts, rotate to other units all the time. We don’t have a list of who else was in and out of this unit during the time but rest assured there were plenty.
3. **Would Walz have a reason to leave before deployment? Of course he would. Who wants to get sent to Iraq for an indeterminate period of time? ** With this question, that you answered yourself so confidently, It’s obvious you never served. If you had served, especially during these conflicts you’d know something. We all wanted to go! Were we scared? Hell yeah, but when the call comes you want to go defend the men & women you have been training alongside of for months, sometimes years. When you train to fight, like mortar units do, you want to go fight. I’m not saying it’s good or bad, that’s just how it is. This is what you signed up for and it’s an honor to serve in that capacity. That being said if you’ve done 2+ decades of service, you’ve done your time combat or not. You don’t make it to E8 or E9 without some character and integrity, so I’m confident that if Tim Walz would have known prior to submitting his retirement package that his soldiers were going down range, to war, he would’ve most likely extended his contract. However, he had other service in mind, and when the deployment notice was given a month later they didn’t even know where the hell they might potentially go in the next 2 years. Should he have signed up for another 4 years (making 28 years in service) just to potentially deploy to Italy again? That’s insanity and just a stupid argument ignorant folks are making. Your “sure deployments are not unforeseen circumstances by those who serve in this role”? You know nothing about service G_Allen. Combat deployments, especially around the time of the surge (which this was) were absolutely unforeseen. You train and prepare but you don’t know where or when you are going in Guard and Reserve units. The only folks who get a hint of a timeline are those in units on active duty who rotate out with their counterpart (sister) units.
4. **But Walz' rank was lowered when he retired which sounds like a form of punishment. Perhaps his superiors were upset at Walz' convenient retirement timing.**. This right here is more evidence of you simply adding your feelings and opinions to the misinformation your chosen outlets are feeding you. Have you people never heard of positional authority or a role appointment? He was a Master Sergeant the command needed a Sergeant Major, they made him the guy. He wasn’t able to retire at that rank officially because he didn’t complete necessary correspondence for the rank (a lot of paperwork and correspondence in the military) and that’s that. Nothing to do with his units leadership or any repercussions to his retirement. #fullstop
5. **After 24 years, Walz could have delayed his retirement to be his unit's leader in a combat theater.**. He was already retired when they were ordered to Iraq in July ’05. You don’t just quit the military and you also don’t just “delay” retirement. That’s just not how it works G_Allen and such an asinine thing to say. Just say it out loud to yourself….”AFTER 24 YEAR, Walz COULD have delayed his retirement to be his unit’s leader…..” #fullstop
6. **falsely insinuating that he served in combat** We’ve went over this one already in a previous comment section. He boned up hard saying he carried a gun in war. We all screw up. He still trained as a war fighter and trained with those weapons, more than you and many of those shouting about it can say I’m sure. Share your “three accounts” or move on from this point you keep trying to make.
G_Allen if you are going to continue this nonsense for the love of humanity post your sources. You said, “from what I’ve read” and “I have read at least three accounts of….” Share them man!? If you are so confident that your sources are the truth, then share them with us. I doubt that you will because you showed your cards with the ridiculous statement that “one person’s truth is another’s falsehood”. What?
The opposite of fact is falsehood. A person who knows nothing is closer to the truth than someone whose mind is full of falsehoods and errors.
If this statement is your truth, then sir you are committed to your ignorance.
Truth is confirmed by inspection and delay; falsehood by haste and uncertainty.
-Tacitus, Roman historian & politician
SOURCE:
https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2024/08/12/walz-faces-republican-criticism-over-timing-of-military-retirement/
https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2024/aug/09/jd-vance/jd-vance-attacked-tim-walz-on-military-record-his/
Hello N. Williams,
Thanks for your service and your thoughtful reply to my post.
The point of my reply to Lisa Braiterman's letter was that "facts" are very debatable and subject to interpretation, and thus trying to label something as "factually inaccurate" when it is an opinion piece, published as a letter to the editor, is not going to be helpful. Everyone who has ever read a newspaper knows (or should know) that letters are from readers, they are meant to respond to things they read in the paper, and they are opinions. Letter writers can cite sources if they wish to make their argument more compelling but there is no ethical requirement to do so.
I did not write the original letter. This is not a topic I would want to spend more than five minutes on. I'd much rather discuss Gov. Walz' Far Left record as Governor, but even that isn't of much interest. We focus on the VP when the pick is made and during their debate, but otherwise most of our focus is on, and should be on, the top of the ticket.
As to my claim that Walz inflated his service record, I cannot give you any personal examples since I never served in the military. And I'm sure if I pointed you to a Fox News or other conservative source, you would say they can't be believed and you would still not be convinced.
So here is the New York Times for ya:
https://www.nytimes.com/2024/08/21/us/politics/tim-walz-military-service.html
And the subhead reads: "Four veterans who investigate claims of fraudulent military service said they do not believe the governor is guilty of “stolen valor,” but that he did misrepresent his record at times."
So if the NYT admits Gov. Walz misrepresented his record "at times" (not the plural of this word), then that settles the issue as far as I am concerned.
On the other main topic, here is a quote from Military.com which says that Walz could have known about his deployment before he retired. Perhaps you know more than the editors of Military.com, but this backs up my supposition:
"After serving in the National Guard for 24 years, Walz retired two months before his unit received official orders for a deployment to Iraq in 2005, though it's possible Walz could have known a deployment order was imminent because he was in a senior enlisted position."
https://www.military.com/daily-news/2024/08/12/tim-walz-military-service-under-attack-trump-campaign-here-are-facts.html
I'm done with this topic, but I hope you can see that even if the sources I just quoted are wrong, trying to "fact check" letters to the editor would be a foolhardy endeavor and would lead to selective censorship. And that's exactly what happened in regards to the Hunter laptop story which was suppressed by the mainstream media and social media.
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.