Lawrence Wittner: Which would you prefer ― nuclear war or climate catastrophe?

kAmuC@>i %96 y@:?E !F3=:4 #6=2E:@?D s6A2CE>6?E @7 E96 vC62E !@H6CDk^Am

kAm%96 H@C=5 @H6D 2? 6?@C>@FD 563E @7 8C2E:EF56 E@ s@?2=5 %CF>A[ '=25:>:C !FE:?[ ): y:?A:?8[ }2C6?5C2 |@5:[ q@C:D y@9?D@? 2?5 @E96C 96C@:4 CF=6CD @7 @FC 8=@C:@FD ?2E:@?D] }@E @?=J 2C6 E96J 92C5 2E H@C< >2<:?8 E96:C C6DA64E:G6 4@F?EC:6D 8C62E 282:?[ 3FE E96J 2C6 AC@G:5:?8 J@F[ E96 A6@A=6 @7 E96 H@C=5[ H:E9 2 49@:46 36EH66? EH@ @AA@CEF?:E:6D 7@C >2DD 562E9 2?5 56DECF4E:@?]k^Am

kAm%9C@F89@FE E96 3C@25 DH66A @7 9:DE@CJ[ =6256CD @7 4@>A6E:?8 E6CC:E@C:6D 2?5 6G6?EF2==J ?2E:@?D =23@C65 2E 7@DE6C:?8 9F>2? 2??:9:=2E:@?[ 3FE[ 8:G6? E96 CF5:>6?E2CJ DE2E6 @7 E96:C E649?@=@8J[ H6C6 @?=J A2CE:2==J DF446DD7F=] *6D[ E96J 5:5 >2?286 E@ D=2F89E6C G2DE ?F>36CD @7 A6@A=6 E9C@F89 C6A62E65 >2DD24C6D 2?5 4@?DE2?E H2CD] %96 %9:CEJ *62CD (2C @7 `e`g\`ecg[ 7@C 6I2>A=6[ C6DF=E65 :? >@C6 E92? 6:89E >:==:@? 42DF2=E:6D[ 2 DF3DE2?E:2= A@CE:@? @7 tFC@A6’D A@AF=2E:@?] p?5[ @7 4@FCD6[ (@C=5 (2CD x 2?5 xx[ DFAA=6>6?E65 3J 2 962CEJ 5@D6 @7 86?@4:56 2=@?8 E96 H2J[ 5:5 2 C6>2C<23=J 8@@5 ;@3 @7 C2G28:?8 A@AF=2E:@?D[ 4C:AA=:?8 E6?D @7 >:==:@?D @7 DFCG:G@CD[ 2?5 3=2DE:?8 >F49 @7 H@C=5 4:G:=:K2E:@? E@ CF33=6] tG6? D@[ 56DA:E6 E96 36DE 677@CED @7 ?2E:@?2= CF=6CD 2?5 E96 ?6G6C\6?5:?8 8=@CJ E96J 56C:G65 7C@> E96D6 6G6?ED[ =2C86 ?F>36CD @7 A6@A=6 D@>69@H DFCG:G65]k^Am

kAm%96C67@C6[ :? pF8FDE `hcd[ E96 CF=6CD @7 E96 8C62E A@H6CD E@@< 2 8C62E =62A 7@CH2C5 H:E9 E96:C 56G6=@A>6?E ― 2?5 :>>65:2E6 FD6 ― @7 2 ?6H[ 25G2?465 :>A=6>6?E 7@C >2DD 56DECF4E:@?i ?F4=62C H62A@?D] w2CCJ %CF>2?[ (:?DE@? r9FC49:== 2?5 y@D6A9 $E2=:? H6C6 2== 6286C E@ 6>A=@J 2E@>:4 3@>3D 282:?DE E96 A6@A=6 @7 y2A2?] &A@? C646:G:?8 E96 ?6HD E92E E96 &]$] 2E@>:4 3@>3:?8 @7 w:C@D9:>2 925 DF446DD7F==J @3=:E6C2E65 E96 A@AF=2E:@? @7 E92E 4:EJ[ %CF>2? C6;@:465 2?5 42==65 E96 24E:@? “E96 8C62E6DE E9:?8 :? 9:DE@CJ]”k^Am

kAmt77@CED E@ 6?92?46 ?2E:@?2= 8C2?56FC 7@==@H65 5FC:?8 DF3D6BF6?E 564256D[ 2D E96 CF=6CD @7 E96 8C62E A@H6CD W2?5 D@>6 A2E96E:4 :>:E2E@CDX 6?82865 :? 2? 6?@C>@FD ?F4=62C 2C>D C246] s6E6C>:?65 E@ 249:6G6 >:=:E2CJ DFAC6>24J[ E96J DA2C65 ?@ 6IA6?D6[ 6>A=@J65 }2K: D4:6?E:DED 2?5 D=2G6 =23@C[ 2?5 D6E @77 G2DE ?F4=62C 6IA=@D:@?D @? E96 =2?5D @7 4@=@?:K65 A6@A=6 2?5 :? E96:C @H? 4@F?EC:6D] qJ E96 `hg_D[ 23@FE f_[___ ?F4=62C H62A@?D H6C6 F?56C E96:C 4@>>2?5 ― >@C6 E92? 6?@F89 E@ 56DEC@J E96 H@C=5 >2?J E:>6D @G6C] w62CE6?65 3J E96:C ?2E:@?2= DEC6?8E9[ @FC CF=6CD E9C6H 5@H? E96 82F?E=6E E@ E96:C 6?6>:6D 2?5 AC65:4E65 E92E E96:C ?2E:@?D H@F=5 6>6C86 G:4E@C:@FD :? 2 ?F4=62C H2C]k^Am

kAmqFE[ 2=2D[ E96 AF3=:4[ 72:=:?8 E@ 2AAC64:2E6 E96D6 G2=:2?E 677@CED[ 8C6H C6DE:G6 ― :?5665[ 5:DEFC3:?8=J F?A2EC:@E:4] p44@C5:?8=J[ E96J 3682? E@ D23@E286 E96D6 25G2?46D 3J 56>2?5:?8 E92E E96:C 8@G6C?>6?ED DE6A 324< 7C@> E96 3C:?< @7 ?F4=62C H2C[ 7@C8@ ?F4=62C 3F:=5FAD[ 2?5 25@AE ?F4=62C 2C>D 4@?EC@= 2?5 5:D2C>2>6?E EC62E:6D] %96 A@AF=2C 4=2>@C 3642>6 D@ 8C62E E92E 6G6? #@?2=5 #6282? ― 2 =@?8E:>6 DFAA@CE6C @7 ?F4=62C DFAC6>24J 2?5 “H:??23=6” ?F4=62C H2CD ― 4CF>A=65] r92>A:@?:?8 ?F4=62C 5:D2C>2>6?E[ 96 3682? 564=2C:?8 E92E “2 ?F4=62C H2C 42??@E 36 H@? 2?5 >FDE ?6G6C 36 7@F89E]” }2E:@?2= 8=@CJ 925 366? D24C:7:465 @? E96 2=E2C @7 2 4@H2C5=J BF6DE 7@C 9F>2? DFCG:G2=]k^Am

kAmu@CEF?2E6=J[ E9@D6 52JD 2C6 =@?8 A2DE] x? E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D[ !C6D:56?E %CF>A :D 56E6C>:?65 E@ C6DE@C6 p>6C:42’D 8C62E?6DD 3J D4C2AA:?8 ?F4=62C 2C>D 4@?EC@= 2?5 5:D2C>2>6?E 28C66>6?ED[ DA6?5:?8 S`]f EC:==:@? @? C67FC3:D9:?8 E96 6?E:C6 &]$] ?F4=62C H62A@?D 4@>A=6I[ 2?5 E9C62E6?:?8 E@ 6C25:42E6 @E96C ?2E:@?D E9C@F89 ?F4=62C H2C] |62?H9:=6[ E96 AC6D:56?E’D 8@@5 7C:6?5D :? |@D4@H[ q6:;:?8[ {@?5@?[ !2C:D[ }6H s6=9:[ 2?5 6=D6H96C6 2C6 3FDJ DAFCC:?8 @? E96:C @H? ?2E:@?2= ?F4=62C H62A@?D 3F:=5FAD] pD E96J C:89E=J :?D:DEi %96 @?=J H2J E@ DE@A 2 325 ?2E:@? H:E9 E96 q@>3 :D H:E9 2 8@@5 ?2E:@? H:E9 E96 q@>3]k^Am

kAm}@C :D E92E 2==P #646?E=J[ @FC CF=6CD 92G6 @A6?65 FA 2 D64@?5 @AA@CEF?:EJ 7@C 2 A=2?6E2CJ 56DECF4E:@?i 4=:>2E6 42E2DEC@A96] $@>6 D4:6?E:DED[ ?6G6C D2E:D7:65 H:E9 =62G:?8 E96 CF??:?8 @7 AF3=:4 2772:CD E@ E96:C H:D6 CF=6CD[ 92G6 4=2:>65 E92E[ E92?<D E@ E96 3FC?:?8 @7 7@DD:= 7F6=D[ C:D:?8 E6>A6C2EFC6D 2C6 >6=E:?8 E96 A@=2C :4642AD[ 96:89E6?:?8 D62 =6G6=D[ 2?5 42FD:?8 >2DD:G6 9FCC:42?6D 2?5 7=@@5D[ 56D6CE:7:42E:@?[ 28C:4F=EFC2= 4@==2AD6 2?5 6?@C>@FD H:=57:C6D] pD 2 C6DF=E[ E96J D2J[ 9F>2? 2?5 @E96C =:76 7@C>D 2C6 @? E96:C H2J E@ 6IE:?4E:@?]k^Am

kAm%96D6 D4:6?E:DED ― 2?5 E96 56=F565 A6@A=6 H9@ 8:G6 E96> 2?J 4C656?46 ― 2C6 >F49 =:<6 E96 4C:E:4D @7 ?F4=62C H62A@?Di D<6AE:4D[ ?2J\D2J6CD 2?5 EC2:E@C@FD=J :?5:776C6?E E@ ?2E:@?2= 8C2?56FC] qJ 4@?EC2DE[ @FC CF=6CD F?56CDE2?5 E92E 2?J 4FC3:?8 @7 E96 FD6 @7 7@DD:= 7F6=D — @C[ 7@C E92E >2EE6C[ 2?J 4FE324<D :? E96 D2=6 @7 E96 AC@5F4ED E92E >2<6 @FC 4@F?EC:6D 8C62E ― H@F=5 :?E6C76C6 H:E9 4@CA@C2E6 AC@7:ED[ F?56C>:?6 3FD:?6DD 8C@HE9 2?5 6IA2?D:@?[ 2?5 C6AC6D6?E 2 C6EC62E 7C@> E96 ?2E:@?2= 8=@CJ E92E :D E96:C 5F6] r@?D6BF6?E=J[ 6G6? :7 3J D@>6 C6>@E6 492?46 H6 2C6 6?E6C:?8 2 A6C:@5 @7 4=:>2E6 5:DCFAE:@?[ @FC CF=6CD H:== C67FD6 E@ 8:G6 H2J 367@C6 E96D6 F?A2EC:@E:4 2EE24<D] pD 4@FC286@FD =6256CD[ E96J H:== ?6G6C C6EC62E 367@C6 E96 AC@DA64E @7 J@FC >2DD 562E9 2?5 56DECF4E:@?]k^Am

kAm(6 2C6 DFC6 E92E J@F[ 2D =@J2= 4:E:K6?D[ 2C6 2D 6?E9FD:2DE:4 2D H6 2C6 23@FE E9:D DE2F?49 5676?D6 @7 ?2E:@?2= 8=@CJ] $@[ :7 J@F ?@E:46 2?J@?6 492==6?8:?8 E9:D 2AAC@249[ A=62D6 ?@E:7J J@FC =@42= w@>6=2?5 $64FC:EJ @77:46] |62?H9:=6[ C6DE 2DDFC65[ @FC 8@G6C?>6?ED H:== 2=D@ 36 4=@D6=J >@?:E@C:?8 E96D6 >2=4@?E6?ED 2?5 DF3G6CD:G6DPk^Am

kAm}2EFC2==J[ J@FC CF=6CD H@F=5 =@G6 E@ 92G6 J@FC 7665324<] %96C67@C6[ H6 2C6 DF3>:EE:?8 E@ J@F E9:D BF6DE:@?i (9:49 H@F=5 J@F AC676C ― 56DECF4E:@? 3J ?F4=62C H2C @C 56DECF4E:@? 3J 4=:>2E6 42E2DEC@A96n }F4=62C H2C H:== 6?5 J@FC 6I:DE6?46 72:C=J BF:4<=J E9C@F89 3=2DE @C 7:C6[ 2=E9@F89 J@FC 562E9 H@F=5 36 D=@H6C 2?5 >@C6 28@?:K:?8 :7 J@F DFCG:G65 =@?8 6?@F89 E@ 5:6 @7 C25:2E:@? D:4<?6DD @C DE2CG2E:@?] ~? E96 @E96C 92?5[ 4=:>2E6 42E2DEC@A96 92D 2AA62=:?8 G2C:6EJ[ 7@C J@F 4@F=5 5:6 3J 7:C6[ H2E6C @C 9F?86C] ~C J@F >:89E D:>A=J C@2DE D=@H=J E92?<D E@ F?362C23=6 E6>A6C2EFC6D]k^Am

kAm(6’5 2AAC64:2E6 C646:G:?8 J@FC @A:?:@? @? E9:D >2EE6C] p7E6C 2==[ AC@G:5:?8 J@F H:E9 E9:D <:?5 @7 49@:46 :D 2 G:E2= A2CE @7 >2<:?8 @FC ?2E:@?D 8C62E 282:?Pk^Am

kAmk6>msC] {2HC6?46 (:EE?6C[ DJ?5:42E65 3J !6246'@:46[ :D !C@76DD@C @7 w:DE@CJ 6>6C:EFD 2E $&}*^p=32?J 2?5 E96 2FE9@C @7 r@?7C@?E:?8 E96 q@>3 W$E2?7@C5 &?:G6CD:EJ !C6DDX]k^6>mk^Am